Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 10 - Page 38

Originally posted by: shiro_shinchan

He’ll be like Miss Mannat meri employee hai aur ek boss ki haisiyat se mera farz banta hai main uski “Har Zaroorat” ka Khayaal Rakhoo

Originally posted by: shiro_shinchan

I doubt Aman track is next. They’ve been hinting at it from the start of the show with Vikku have FBs over a month ago. I feel they’ll drag this bobby drama for another 2 weeks and post that love realisation may begin from Vikku & then Mannat’s side. There’s no logic in introducing Aman’s track when leads haven’t realised their feelings!

I believe show is at least safe till IPL. Post IPL, it’d depend on the TRPs. But given its online popularity, I doubt the channel would be looney to shut it down. Afaik there’s no show of colors trending online on hotstar except Mannat which has left behind even Upma & Rishta in terms on online viewing! It’s the most viewed TV show on that platform off late!

@bold Wow ... Ok I don't know that

@red really hope so... Really looking forward for some light hearted episodes

Hi kash, I know you make awesome vm, could you make one for saluja brothers similar to the one with Salvatore brothers from vampire diaries...

https://youtube.com/shorts/r7xizCYlXik?si=YNSpCYIDCF51dMli

Punnu and vikranth in this pic reminds me of Salvatore brothers

https://x.com/Vyshnav30192907/status/1914566728320946518

Please make one if possible

Looks like for people like us https://www.instagram.com/reel/DGsygtDTTcx/?igsh=c2RubzkxMmZsMDgx

Originally posted by: Moor278

After watching the full episode and ManVik for the second time.... my thoughts on that scene are the same!!!

Partly I agree could be the expectations (mere apne hi ).... the scene, anticipation, BTSs, Mukta song choice everything suggested something more... if not ILU.... and it did feel a little less in comparison...

Also, for me... "Adhuri Kahani" is a standout scene so far.... best out of all their scenes....and none of ones that followed have lived up to that one!!!

I was probably also expecting a reverse of Adhuri Kahani... something more honest and passionate (not of the 18+ variety )

Vikrant got an easy apology.... Mannat forgave him far too quickly... she does have a soft corner but it was quick considering how much she suffered in all this.... and to top it off.... gave all the credit to him... sure only voice and his conviction would have mattered to his family and anything Mannat did would not have made a difference.... it still doesnt.... but to say he made it happen and that he is BKB for everyone is not true.... thankfully Vik did not agree to this!!!!

The other thing is ofcourse the last frame... of Malla in between them.... I thought I have grown out of that.... but that shot itself brings back so many horrible memories which I dont want to be in this show!!!! Please Mukta... dont do this.... Malla still doesnt bother me... but it bothers when the leads ka scene is disturbed due to external elements

That apart the scene (when its just the two) was wonderful.... beautifully executed and emoted by the two... their faces and eyes speaks volumes and lot of unsaid feelings were visible to the audience....

Maybe it was the camera angle or something Adnan did... but he made himself small... like physically .. when he says main sharminda hun.... that says a lot!!! and Mannat becomes the bigger person... metaphorically... her smaller physical frame is able to calm him down...

Vikku boy definitely got the 'pheels' today!!! and yes (I agree Rdigest...) he would have gone for a kiss if Malla had not disturbed...

There was a blink and miss moment where his nose slid down hers.... it was too cute and intimate at the same time

@Kash... you need to make a compilation of all the "tum thik ho?"... all of them have different emotions!!!

Have no words for Raveena.... absolute trash...... she is blaming Vik for something he corrected without a thought on how wrong Bobby was...

Neetu ajeeb hoti jaa rahi hai.... when Vikrant says Bobby is wrong or should be punished... she nods appreciatively and proudly ki wah re mera beta!!!! but Mannat says the same thing,... she gets upset...

Same goes with ARS, Malla ...

Saare ke saare Mannat pe naraz hai... for bringing out the truth... without having a thought on how horrible the truth is...

Also, all Malla has to do is tell Mannat that she likes Vik now and Mannat backoff karegi... but nahi... Malla ego trip pe hai... (and Mukta episode badhane main)...

Puneet's dialogue for parents seems like a premonition.... that come whatever may... you will have to choose your parents!!!

I still think Mannat ka next task is Nikhil ki family ko patao ... give some gyaan about not to take out Bobbys anger on Anu.... probably win some brownie points from Punnu.... he was subdued today but he didnt protest... Abeer made it look like he agreed with the proceedings... even if its not what he wanted...

Mukta ji... do yaar Punnu ke saath triangle... such a waste of talent for him to be just chef!!!!

Gagan my boy... sober raha kar... acchha lagta hai

P.S. I wish Mannat had not asked Shalini to slap bobby... Vik saying it was enough... Mannat should have stayed quiet...

I have not watched bts lately, so there was no expectation for me, but its obvious there were scenes cut from today and yesterday episode. Shalini said Vikrant is BKB, cut to hugging Mannat when Raveena fainted.

Mannat always give BOD and long rope, especially to those who have been by her side. Vikrant and Malla too got quick forgiveness, she understood their perspective, it was about family, although Malla had different reason. Being understanding and forgiving is a good thing, but I hope in the future she would draw a line at some point.

I did not like Mannat giving all the credit to Vikrant too. About BKB for everyone, I think it was in the sense of standing with Shalini..he would do that for everyone.

Raveena never consider Vikrant as family, for her its easier to blame outsider. Just like those blaming Mannat, because she is not wealthy like them.

There was another dialogue from Mannat yesterday, but the premonition is opposite of Puneet dialogue.

About Nikhil family, I am not familiar with the actors, could they be here for long?

Agree about Abeer, he is such a talented actor, give us the triangle.

Gagan is making things more interesting, now ARS too is curious about Aman. Who will find out what first and how will they use it?

I would prefer if both Vikrant and Mannat did not ask Shalini to slap Bobby, Shalini slapping because of Bobby words felt more apt. Even I felt like slapping him then. And I did not like the 'pairon ke neeche' dialog.

I have seen ss of Doree trending on JioHotstar.

Does online views bring profit or make up for trp? I have seen other trending shows going under scanner or axed because of low trp.

Anyone watching the first episode could've never imagined that malla will turn out to be a wolf in sheeps clothing. Ekdum se she has become so clever jaise kitne ekta ke shows dekh lio ho isne.

Kya mukta tai rectangle banao na re, what's with every tv show maker's obsession with trikon.

Originally posted by: Moor278

After watching the full episode and ManVik for the second time.... my thoughts on that scene are the same!!!

Partly I agree could be the expectations (mere apne hi ).... the scene, anticipation, BTSs, Mukta song choice everything suggested something more... if not ILU.... and it did feel a little less in comparison...

Also, for me... "Adhuri Kahani" is a standout scene so far.... best out of all their scenes....and none of ones that followed have lived up to that one!!!

I was probably also expecting a reverse of Adhuri Kahani... something more honest and passionate (not of the 18+ variety )

Vikrant got an easy apology.... Mannat forgave him far too quickly... she does have a soft corner but it was quick considering how much she suffered in all this.... and to top it off.... gave all the credit to him... sure only voice and his conviction would have mattered to his family and anything Mannat did would not have made a difference.... it still doesnt.... but to say he made it happen and that he is BKB for everyone is not true.... thankfully Vik did not agree to this!!!!

The other thing is ofcourse the last frame... of Malla in between them.... I thought I have grown out of that.... but that shot itself brings back so many horrible memories which I dont want to be in this show!!!! Please Mukta... dont do this.... Malla still doesnt bother me... but it bothers when the leads ka scene is disturbed due to external elements

That apart the scene (when its just the two) was wonderful.... beautifully executed and emoted by the two... their faces and eyes speaks volumes and lot of unsaid feelings were visible to the audience....

Maybe it was the camera angle or something Adnan did... but he made himself small... like physically .. when he says main sharminda hun.... that says a lot!!! and Mannat becomes the bigger person... metaphorically... her smaller physical frame is able to calm him down...

Vikku boy definitely got the 'pheels' today!!! and yes (I agree Rdigest...) he would have gone for a kiss if Malla had not disturbed...

There was a blink and miss moment where his nose slid down hers.... it was too cute and intimate at the same time

@Kash... you need to make a compilation of all the "tum thik ho?"... all of them have different emotions!!!

Have no words for Raveena.... absolute trash...... she is blaming Vik for something he corrected without a thought on how wrong Bobby was...

Neetu ajeeb hoti jaa rahi hai.... when Vikrant says Bobby is wrong or should be punished... she nods appreciatively and proudly ki wah re mera beta!!!! but Mannat says the same thing,... she gets upset...

Same goes with ARS, Malla ...

Saare ke saare Mannat pe naraz hai... for bringing out the truth... without having a thought on how horrible the truth is...

Also, all Malla has to do is tell Mannat that she likes Vik now and Mannat backoff karegi... but nahi... Malla ego trip pe hai... (and Mukta episode badhane main)...

Puneet's dialogue for parents seems like a premonition.... that come whatever may... you will have to choose your parents!!!

I still think Mannat ka next task is Nikhil ki family ko patao ... give some gyaan about not to take out Bobbys anger on Anu.... probably win some brownie points from Punnu.... he was subdued today but he didnt protest... Abeer made it look like he agreed with the proceedings... even if its not what he wanted...

Mukta ji... do yaar Punnu ke saath triangle... such a waste of talent for him to be just chef!!!!

Gagan my boy... sober raha kar... acchha lagta hai

P.S. I wish Mannat had not asked Shalini to slap bobby... Vik saying it was enough... Mannat should have stayed quiet...

Bold- yess it's my fav as well, everything was just right! Their was passion,angst, love, eagerness, pain at not being trusted and yearning to be understood. It hit all the right chords.

Red- I know right! Too easy of an apology for all that she went through it was. Puri pighal gayi ek baar mai, it was as if she knew he required her to be closeby for all that happened sometime before.

He was shell shocked to know Bobbie was the person afterall that happened. And to double the hurt, the pain was the betrayal from not just one member but from everyone whom he called his family. What ached him most was that his parents hid the truth from him, knowing he would not be able to himself in the mirror when the truth comes out.

So in that moment he was just not able to talk to mannat, whilv meeting her eyes. Adnan portrayed the shame in his eyes really well. U could see that he was apologetic and distraught. Sharmindagi jhalak rahi thi uski aankhon se.

And mannat became the bigger person here. Apologized and even gave all the credit to him. U know I kinda liked this scene, she forgave him too easily. This will have a more profound impact on vikrant, than any other way of him apologizing or mannat taking time to forgive. Showing nakhra which would have been absolutely right and understandable. But I like this one more because jo dard usko uski aasan maafi degi, he would remember her kindness all way along and ensure that he never repeats what he did again. kabhi kabhi jab aasani se maafi mil jaati hai toh we tend to think and be in awe of the person, it pierces her heart when we ponder over our actions and realise how much pain one's actions might have caused to the other person. Kyunki hume tab sirf humara galat kiya hua aur saamne waale ka aasani se maaf karna yaad rehta. And we become small in our eyes.

This will make him fall for her much harder, he is and will always be awed by her kindness!!

BUT PLEASE NO NEED FOR HER TO RELY UPON VIKRANT FOR ANYTHING AT ALL FROM NOW ON.

I can kinda relate to mannat, it's quite a difficult task to remain angry for long, our braincells keep justifying other person's action by giving one of another explanation. But we don't forget any of the things that they did to us, their words are their engraved in our mind, a GAP comes which is the hardest to fill. And is the real punishment for the other person.

ALSO ONE MORE THING I BELIEVE IN IS THAT MAAFI JOOTE RAGAD KAR MANGO YA SIRF DO SACHE SHABD BOLE KE, JO BOLO FEEL IT. AND A SITUATION WHERE U HAVE TO REPEAT IT SHOULD NEVER ARISE AGAIN!! PHIR WOH INSAAN REDEMPTION LAYAK BHI NAHI REHTA MERI NAZRO MAI!!

Originally posted by: MeeraWrites

Vikrant was not so okay with Malla's sudden entry.

Uske Kuch aur hee plan thee, Jo Malla nye paani pher diya