Shrimad Ramayan Chat club #3 - Page 96

Chat clubs

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.4k

Views

31.3k

Users

13

Likes

2k

Frequent Posters

cuteamanboy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: RamAayenge

Yeh canon thread pe hua tha UK happened or not wala discussion...check it if it's there...

ok i will check thanks for sharing the link

Celinacrescent thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail 1st Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: cuteamanboy

what are your views regarding uttar kand as many claim it's interpolated some say even the same about bal kand

The Uttarkand is in many ways inconsistent with the writings that we have read in the first 6 main काण्ड or sections.

There are 2 schools of thought for this - one says that Uttarkand is an interpolation .

In Uttarkand it says .

Ram then bids farewell to 100s of Kings who had gathered in Ayoddhya because Bharat has called them to fight Ravana .Now that is incorrect because we know that in previous kand that is Ayoddhya kand ,Hanuman goes to meet Bharat to stop him from suicide after the war.This was the first time ever when he heard about the whole story of Ram in exile from Hanuman.

Second Ravan is shown as a weakling in Uttar kand.He was a great warrior till Yuddha kand and he would Never bend.He says in Yuddha kand that even if he is cut into 2 pieces after the death of his generals and while family,he will never bend.But in Uttarkand ,he gets into fights then he is captured and then he makes a truce.Then his grandfather comes to release him etc.

If you read it carefully, you will find that, there is Phal Shruti added by Maharishi Vaalmiki at the end of Yuddha Kaand, stating that for 11,000 years in the reign of Sri Ram and Devi Sita, conducted thousands of Ashwamedh Yajna and, everything was prosperous during their reign. Which means, the original Vaalmiki Ramayanam ended at the Yuddha Kaand ! That is, only six books are considered to be part of authentic Vaalmiki Ramayanam. Whereas, another Phal Shruti is given at the end of Uttara Kaand, which doesn't makes sense !

In Mahabharata also, katha of Ramayana is told to Yudhisthir. In that katha also, there is no mention of Uttara Kaand. That means, till Mahabharata, Ramayana ended in Yuddha Kaand only. Uttara Kaand was added much later.

In 2015, an ancient manuscript of Valmiki Ramayana was found in a Sanskrit library in Kolkata. It is from the 500s C.E., older than all other surviving manuscripts yet discovered. The Uttara Kanda does not appear in it at all. So that is pretty good evidence.


However Vaishnavites believed that it happened and generally have great contempt for those who believe that it didn't happen.Boty the schools have enough reason to believe in it.BORI critical version excludes Uttar kand .at the end of the day,take away from the epic is more important ,I believe .

SilverBell thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: cuteamanboy

what are your views regarding uttar kand as many claim it's interpolated some say even the same about bal kand

I Just Enjoy The Story Only

MJ_1009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 1 years ago

what's up guys? kaise sab log? aaj kya hua?

SilverBell thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

Good Night 😴

Chatterbox Pete

And Friends

Iam Going Out Now

See You Tomorrow

chatterbox thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: SilverBell

Good Night 😴

Chatterbox Pete

And Friends

Iam Going Out Now

See You Tomorrow

Oh good night

My morning started now

Enjoy

Err u said u r not free as guests coming

Do u want me to tag u for upcoming episode reviews

chatterbox thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: MJ_1009

what's up guys? kaise sab log? aaj kya hua?

Hello good morning

Jai shree Ram

All good woke up late

Luckily hubby had made tea so Aaj jaldi chai pi li

U say what's up

U watching episodes

chatterbox thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

Hi pete which comedy show u went to watch .. I was playing online games but ek bhi game complet nahi kar paayi.

Zombies hi dikh rahe the

CID-fan-394 thumbnail

Panchavati Peacekeepers

Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: chatterbox

Hi pete which comedy show u went to watch .. I was playing online games but ek bhi game complet nahi kar paayi.

Zombies hi dikh rahe the

Not a show....i was watching Shinchan to forget about that horror threadsmiley36

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/hollywood/5364521/dive-into-iconic-hollywood-horror-share-your-scariest-picks

cuteamanboy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

aj image upload or external image ka option a rha h reply section me

but image upload krne ke bad a rha h

some error occurred please try again later

tried many times but same result

please help

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".