Madhuri or Aishwarya.Who is the better actress? - Page 3

Hum Aapke Hain Koun, Saajan, Khal Nayak, Beta, even Dil were all time blockbusters which Aishwarya Rai can only dream of. Aishwarya Rai only has Dhoom 2 as an all time blockbuster. That is pathetic.
Madhuri was the number one disputed queen in 1990, 1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995. Aishwarya was only number one in 2000 and 2002.

This poll is a joke . You already know my answer

Originally posted by: fazgostoso

In what universe does Aish have more hits than Madhuri? Aishwarya has only 6 hits in her career out of a 45-50 filmography. And Madhuri had more than 10. Aishwarya is not globally famous. Her 5 so-called Hollywood films are disasters with the exception of Bride and Prejudice which flopped in India. Pink Panther 2 and Last Legion are super flops worldwide. And Aishwarya was critically panned in Chokher Bali. Raima Sen stole the show from her.

I suggest you do your research first and then we can talk.

Originally posted by: MrChatVsNorway

According to them , Ash is bigger than Angelina Jolie

Yes they are not accepting facts. Madhuri had an amazing box office record as a leading lady. In fact, most of her films were successful because of her. I didn’t watch Khal Nayak because of Sanjay Dutt. I watched the movie only for her

Both have their limitations, however I always thought that Madhuri looked more like an aunty to me. Even in DTPH she gave me “40 year old with 2 small kids” vibes.

Is this even a question Madhuri of course, I watched that OTT fest Devdas because of Madhuri. She turned out to be the best out of 3 SRK & Jackie Sheroff were OTT and Aish was monotonous.

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

Both have their limitations, however I always thought that Madhuri looked more like an aunty to me. Even in DTPH she gave me “40 year old with 2 small kids” vibes.

Offcourse Aishwarya Rai.

Madhuri was an item girl before becoming an actress. She rose to fame because of her item songs Ek Do Teen, Oye Oye & Choli Ke Peeche.

Madhuri had 10 hits

Ram Lakhan

Dil

Beta

Hum Apke Hai Kaun

Khalnayak

Saajan

Raja

Dil To Pagal Hai

Pukar

& her last hit was

Devdas with Aishwarya Rai.

Aishwarya Rai has 14 hits

First hit was Jeans, not only hit but blockbuster. Its Hindi dubbed version was also hit.

Jeans

Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam

Taal

Josh

Kandukondain Kandukondain

Hamara Dil Apke Paas Hai

Devdas

Chokher Bali

Bride & Prejudice

Dhoom 2

Guru

Jodhaa Akbar

Raavanan

Endhiran - The Robot

Ponniyin Selvan

Even her flop Guzaarish is considered a classic film.

I also like Madhuri but you have to agree that Madhuri's career was already over in 1995 with Raja.

Dil To Pagal Hai was not her film at all.

It was SRK-Karishma's film. All those Maya Maya bullshit was super annoying. She also looked like a 40 something aunty in the film. A misfit for that role.

Madhuri is more of an item girl of 80's and early 90's rather than an actress. First she was a dancer, then she was an actress.

Both are a tie for me...as far as acting skills are concerned.

Stardom definietly Madhuri above Aishwarya.

Originally posted by: Mugda

Offcourse Aishwarya Rai.

Madhuri was an item girl before becoming an actress. She rose to fame because of her item songs Ek Do Teen, Oye Oye & Choli Ke Peeche.

Madhuri had 10 hits

Ram Lakhan

Dil

Beta

Hum Apke Hai Kaun

Khalnayak

Saajan

Raja

Dil To Pagal Hai

Pukar

& her last hit was

Devdas with Aishwarya Rai.

Aishwarya Rai has 14 hits

First hit was Jeans, not only hit but blockbuster. Its Hindi dubbed version was also hit.

Jeans

Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam

Taal

Josh

Kandukondain Kandukondain

Hamara Dil Apke Paas Hai

Devdas

Chokher Bali

Bride & Prejudice

Dhoom 2

Guru

Jodhaa Akbar

Raavanan

Endhiran - The Robot

Ponniyin Selvan

Even her flop Guzaarish is considered a classic film.

I also like Madhuri but you have to agree that Madhuri's career was already over in 1995 with Raja.

Dil To Pagal Hai was not her film at all.

It was SRK-Karishma's film. All those Maya Maya bullshit was super annoying. She also looked like a 40 something aunty in the film. A misfit for that role.

Madhuri is more of an item girl of 80's and early 90's rather than an actress. First she was a dancer, then she was an actress.

Mugda, you are wrong about Aishwarya’s hits. Josh was average. Kandukondain Kandukondain and Jeans are south films, don’t count. Chokher Bali and Bride and Prejudice are flops in India. Raavanan, Robot, and Ponniyan Selvan are south films, don’t count. She only has 6 hits. Jodhaa Akbar was a semi-hit.
I only count Aish’s hits as HDDCS, Taal, Devdas, HDAPH, Dhoom 2, and Guru. Madhuri’s hits are more impactful and she carried the films on her own name. Aishwarya Rai is a superflop actress and her record is even worse than Rani and Kareena. Stop being so biased and accept facts. Aishwarya Rai is a pathetic actress and box office is way below Madhuri.