🏏IPL 2026: SRH vs RR, 21st Match,Hyderabad 13 Apr 7:30pm IST🏏
🏏IPL 2026: CSK vs KKR, 22nd Match,Chennai 14 Apr 7:30pm IST🏏
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 41
12.4 and 13.4 episodes
A Film Doesn’t Feel Like Propaganda If You Never Pause to Notice
TRUTH IS OUT 14.4
The Yrkkh Gen 5 Discussions Thread
Namit Malhotra To Take Forward Brahmastra 2
Varun Will Star In Vivek Agnihotri's Operation Sindoor ?
Noyna signs off for now
Is Ek Din a magic realism romance?
So I see some false narratives floating around about Abhimanyu again that I feel deserve a fact check 😆
a) Abhimanyu speaking up about Manjiri’s pain is same as Akshara speaking about Nav’s pain as father all the time. Hain? 😕😆
Abhimanyu never disrespected Nav’s rights as a father - infact he always made sure to acknowledge Nav as a father at every point. Ak dragged Nav in every time to glorify him whenever Abhi talked about his own pain as a father. Today, Akshara was the one to drag in Manjiri and accuse her of being selfish - only THEN Abhi spoke up about his mom’s pain as any son would. It is a false equivalence to say these two situations are the same.
b) Ab clearly pointed out that he is not invalidating Akshara’s pain as a mom, he is simply asking that his mom’s pain not be invalidated either. But no one seems to have heard this and are claiming he blindly defended his mom 🤷♀️😂. He literally acknowledged that his mom is insecure and made many mistakes but this is being called blind defense?
Meanwhile Akshara has to date never acknowledged any mistake of Nav and glorifies him blindly even when he’s not involved in any topic. Lol
c) Ak screamed at Ab for 10 minutes and he only fired back for 3 minutes when she crossed the line by disrespecting his mom to his face.
Wonder how Ak would have reacted if either Naira or Seerat were alive and someone would have called them selfish in front of her 🤔
👏👏 people who blindly want to find fault with AB will not see any logic. It’s best to ignore.
She had the audacity to call AB paraya again and people still think she is mother teresa and on top she calls Manjari selfish 🤷🏻♀️ hypocrite 😡 I’m glad that weekend visitation rights is also revoked.
Originally posted by: Avanti30
In that case she waited for months and he did not come . She is obviously turned vile because her heart was broken because it was her Abhi ....
Now coming to her leaving abhi here when she first came to UD and took the bike and went to BH when abhir was ill ..I don't understand how come at GH or at BH she did not have any memories of herself atleast if not with Abhi ....
Writer is completely thrown her away from her own story where she once existed and except for wd Abhi was always supportive of her and taken care of even during pregnancy and this women is either has become gazini and forgotten things or doing it purposefully...
I blame the writers..they have divided this show into 2 parts. Pre Leap and post leap don't have any connection with each other nor any consistency in characters. Characters are behaving in their own way...even story each day is different...Aarohi has suddenly become a saint...Manjari a vamp...Akshara has been most ruined...
Originally posted by: Neerasi29
Actually I think they didn't show what happened in between properly ..a lot of it is open to interpretation and assumption..or may be I haven't understood it well..after how much time did she tell about her marriage...what happened in between..I can distinctly remember white day and then 6 years after episodes. To be honest day she married Abhinav I have been missing watching show regularly..just looking at clips..Ffding episodes..I read summary of episode here and watch it if it's good else skip it completely..did Abhi try to approach her or he didn't after hearing her getting married...all i feel a lot of it was misunderstanding between all..one event after other got escalated..even Goenka family didn't go looking for her. TBH they were in hurry to get that dramatic TRP boost of leap and white day ..I didn't find it very organic
So the episodes goes like:
WD happened and next day Abhinav met Akshara. AK was in state of trauma and fainted Nav took her to hospital where she got to know about one baby. She called AbhiM but here Abhimanyu was dealing with Manjari as she was admitted and same time MJ saw Akshu name in ph so she got out of control.
Then Mahima said don't keep doing Akshu Akshu and Here BP got to know Ak is in pathankot she called Abhi but he said he won't come.
When Ak saw BP
Bp said some BS which wasn't entirely true so she didn't go in front of him and her friend conveyed that BP should go back.
2-3 passed on where she faced some issues, then she got a job too but that guy mis behaved Nav was always there somehow. Then he took her to his place said he have no one (still can't get why not mention Neelama and mUski) any way. Between these 2-3 days AbhiM once visited Goenka house he asked if Akshu is fine but BP and BM bashed him and said she is happy without him and won't come. They didn't say k unse nhi mili
During these days sometime Abhi called Akshara back too but Nav picked and when Abhi asked who are you he said Mr India and all. Abhi got angery and said nahi matlb Ak se bache se kisi se nahi
Which was heard by Ak and she said nahi sunna hai na ab jab chahega bhi tab bhi nahi kahungi and I feel this is what she has been doing ever since.
Then cut to 6-7 months. Things got little better at BH so they thought chalo manju bday mna lete hain to refresh mood
Here toofani raat huyi and when she woke up she made Nav the father.
Then during manju party BP gave his ph to Abhi to click selfie but Ak called and Abhi by mistake picked up and she said Maine shaadi karli hai.
Abhi walked out and then leap.
Ek ek scene yaad hai mereko 😎
Originally posted by: Nothingtosay
👏👏 people who blindly want to find fault with AB will not see any logic. It’s best to ignore.
She had the audacity to call AB paraya again and people still think she is mother teresa and on top she calls Manjari selfish 🤷🏻♀️ hypocrite 😡 I’m glad that weekend visitation rights is also revoked.
Lol but this time it was clearer than ever that there is no basis to these false narratives today. The sequence of events was very clear today about who incited the argument by screaming and disrespecting and who responded after being accused. Ab didn’t do any blind jaap. So I felt it was worth pointing out.
Usually false narratives are pushed when there is lack of information or clarity. But aaj toh sab clear cut tha 😆
And I also wanted to point out that Ak never seems to wonder how she would react if someone talked this disrespectfully about her mom in front of her 🤷♀️….just because people keep cursing Manjiri here doesn’t mean that she isn’t still a mom. And no child will tolerate their mom being disrespected to their face like Ak did to AB’s mom today. Same way Abhir was upset when he felt his mom was disrespected. It holds true on all sides. Ak doesn’t get to have special rules for herself.
Originally posted by: chaipaani
So the episodes goes like:
WD happened and next day Abhinav met Akshara. AK was in state of trauma and fainted Nav took her to hospital where she got to know about one baby. She called AbhiM but here Abhimanyu was dealing with Manjari as she was admitted and same time MJ saw Akshu name in ph so she got out of control.
Then Mahima said don't keep doing Akshu Akshu and Here BP got to know Ak is in pathankot she called Abhi but he said he won't come.
When Ak saw BP
Bp said some BS which wasn't entirely true so she didn't go in front of him and her friend conveyed that BP should go back.
2-3 passed on where she faced some issues, then she got a job too but that guy mis behaved Nav was always there somehow. Then he took her to his place said he have no one (still can't get why not mention Neelama and mUski) any way. Between these 2-3 days AbhiM once visited Goenka house he asked if Akshu is fine but BP and BM bashed him and said she is happy without him and won't come. They didn't say k unse nhi mili
During these days sometime Abhi called Akshara back too but Nav picked and when Abhi asked who are you he said Mr India and all. Abhi got angery and said nahi matlb Ak se bache se kisi se nahi
Which was heard by Ak and she said nahi sunna hai na ab jab chahega bhi tab bhi nahi kahungi and I feel this is what she has been doing ever since.
Then cut to 6-7 months. Things got little better at BH so they thought chalo manju bday mna lete hain to refresh mood
Here toofani raat huyi and when she woke up she made Nav the father.
Then during manju party BP gave his ph to Abhi to click selfie but Ak called and Abhi by mistake picked up and she said Maine shaadi karli hai.
Abhi walked out and then leap.
Ek ek scene yaad hai mereko 😎
You remember everything in so much details😊
O yes .I remember snippets of it...so Abhi was under impression she has been taken care of by Goenkas and they did tell Abhi to go away and stay away from her..
Lol but this time it was clearer than ever that there is no basis to these false narratives today. The sequence of events was very clear today about who incited the argument by screaming and disrespecting and who responded after being accused. Ab didn’t do any blind jaap. So I felt it was worth pointing out.
Usually false narratives are pushed when there is lack of information or clarity. But aaj toh sab clear cut tha 😆
And I also wanted to point out that Ak never seems to wonder how she would react if someone talked this disrespectfully about her mom in front of her 🤷♀️….just because people keep cursing Manjiri here doesn’t mean that she isn’t still a mom. And no child will tolerate their mom being disrespected to their face like Ak did to AB’s mom today. Same way Abhir was upset when he felt his mom was disrespected. It holds true on all sides. Ak doesn’t get to have special rules for herself.
As if your voice is audible to the people who set this narrative
Originally posted by: Neerasi29
You remember everything in so much details😊
O yes .I remember snippets of it...so Abhi was under impression she has been taken care of by Goenkas and they did tell Abhi to go away and stay away from her..
No so he thought Goenkas are aware of her whereabouts.
During that time he was like it's best we stay apart but care k liye he asked and they told him she is safe and happy so he focused on what was left behind his mother and Neil's hone wala baby
Yeh show mein bhi hoga tho kitna acha lagega ....I want all 3 kids to have great bond with poppy, dadda and chahu ...
Phir Abhir will say bye bye to Ak and papa ...i would love to see he taking sides with Abhi...dadda
But itna jaldi AbhiM ko Kushi koi de saktha hain kya 😔
It will never surprise me more that how two people who are all grown up almost in their 30s and 40s respectively behave like 15 year old idiots...
Hello folks, Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread #2 for Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Please keep these Rules in mind while posting . Please...
Hello folks, Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread #1 for Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Please keep these Rules in mind while posting . Please...
Yrkkh isnt just a show but a vital part of India's Pop Culture and often credited to be India's longest show.Log Nursery se graduate hogaye but...
Welcome to Episode Discussion Thread
1