stunninstar thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#1

I really feel YRKKH has lost the basic essence.. Main thing with the show from S1 was how relatable it was for common man - even though they were showing it from an elite class family.. Naitik and Akshara were what a real husband wife were like.. they had their shares of fights and problems but no constant villains in story!


Reaching upto S3 the story has lost this charm.. It has become so toxic to a normal man..


1/ Abhimanyu is so blinded by mother love.. His character was supposed to be fighting for his lover against the world - including his mom..


2/ Akshu is a spineless woman.. FL in itv has to be a little more preacher.. In real life too I dont think people will be so silent and loving towards people who hates you, to those who tried to hit you at your lowest,.. how can she fold her hands and be like nothing happened.. normal human will never ever look at such ppl!


3/ Abhinav- I love Jay soni and this character nav too.. He was supposed to be the “Mr. Bajaj” here.. But with someone like Harshad as the main lead, jay soni doesnt match.. I am not saying Jay isnt a good actor.. but i feel this role should have been played by someone like Shaheer or Arjun.. This is even if Abhinav is a short lived role.. Otherwise people will always try to see the good in Abhimanyu character irrespective of his character’s toxicity!

I have been huge huge fan of Harshad since Kis desh m days.. have followed all his work.. still I hate his character Abhimanyu.. no one will wish for a husband like him.. he is only a momma boy.. nothing else..

For once I want Abhinav and Akshara to blast everyone.. Open their mouth and back answer Manjari maata!

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

2.2k

Users

11

Likes

72

Frequent Posters

Priyrabha thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: stunninstar

I really feel YRKKH has lost the basic essence.. Main thing with the show from S1 was how relatable it was for common man - even though they were showing it from an elite class family.. Naitik and Akshara were what a real husband wife were like.. they had their shares of fights and problems but no constant villains in story!


Reaching upto S3 the story has lost this charm.. It has become so toxic to a normal man..


1/ Abhimanyu is so blinded by mother love.. His character was supposed to be fighting for his lover against the world - including his mom..


2/ Akshu is a spineless woman.. FL in itv has to be a little more preacher.. In real life too I dont think people will be so silent and loving towards people who hates you, to those who tried to hit you at your lowest,.. how can she fold her hands and be like nothing happened.. normal human will never ever look at such ppl!


3/ Abhinav- I love Jay soni and this character nav too.. He was supposed to be the “Mr. Bajaj” here.. But with someone like Harshad as the main lead, jay soni doesnt match.. I am not saying Jay isnt a good actor.. but i feel this role should have been played by someone like Shaheer or Arjun.. This is even if Abhinav is a short lived role.. Otherwise people will always try to see the good in Abhimanyu character irrespective of his character’s toxicity!

I have been huge huge fan of Harshad since Kis desh m days.. have followed all his work.. still I hate his character Abhimanyu.. no one will wish for a husband like him.. he is only a momma boy.. nothing else..

For once I want Abhinav and Akshara to blast everyone.. Open their mouth and back answer Manjari maata!


Because makers are confusing everyone. If abhira is endgame then should not turn Abhimanyu like this or not give hopes for another ship. Kasauli track was better because everyone was clr that abhira is endgame and nav is cupid the marriage was also not confirmed. But after that they changed the story make another ship. People who love Abhinav now love AkshNav also. So they can clr everything that who is endgame and give us mukti.

Sushma_00 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: stunninstar

I really feel YRKKH has lost the basic essence.. Main thing with the show from S1 was how relatable it was for common man - even though they were showing it from an elite class family.. Naitik and Akshara were what a real husband wife were like.. they had their shares of fights and problems but no constant villains in story!


Reaching upto S3 the story has lost this charm.. It has become so toxic to a normal man..


1/ Abhimanyu is so blinded by mother love.. His character was supposed to be fighting for his lover against the world - including his mom..


2/ Akshu is a spineless woman.. FL in itv has to be a little more preacher.. In real life too I dont think people will be so silent and loving towards people who hates you, to those who tried to hit you at your lowest,.. how can she fold her hands and be like nothing happened.. normal human will never ever look at such ppl!


3/ Abhinav- I love Jay soni and this character nav too.. He was supposed to be the “Mr. Bajaj” here.. But with someone like Harshad as the main lead, jay soni doesnt match.. I am not saying Jay isnt a good actor.. but i feel this role should have been played by someone like Shaheer or Arjun.. This is even if Abhinav is a short lived role.. Otherwise people will always try to see the good in Abhimanyu character irrespective of his character’s toxicity!

I have been huge huge fan of Harshad since Kis desh m days.. have followed all his work.. still I hate his character Abhimanyu.. no one will wish for a husband like him.. he is only a momma boy.. nothing else..

For once I want Abhinav and Akshara to blast everyone.. Open their mouth and back answer Manjari maata!


Please....the acting level of Harshad as Abhimanyu is nauseating.....People can't even differentiate whether he is sad or guilty or regret with his expressions....Jay Soni is definitely a better actor as Abhinav because he brought the freshness and innocence to the character Abhinav.

stunninstar thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Sushma_Reddy


Please....the acting level of Harshad as Abhimanyu is nauseating.....People can't even differentiate whether he is sad or guilty or regret with his expressions....Jay Soni is definitely a better actor as Abhinav because he brought the freshness and innocence to the character Abhinav.

Jay soni is an amazing actor.. Harshad is a bigger star is what I meant.. as per the fanbase and past work followers.. i am not belittling Jay .. dont take it wrong!

If you have seen KZK you will get what I meant.. Anurag and Prerna the soul couples by shweta tiwari and Cezanne.. If Bajaj was accepted and loved thT was coz of Ronit Roy.. Had it been an actor of lesser reach, i am sure the story would have diverted there..



I dont want thT here.. i want Akshara to never go back and get abused by Manjari.. I want Abhinav to get his dues .. and I want Abhimanyu to repent for the anger he hadZz

MyThoughts thumbnail
5th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Sushma_Reddy


Please....the acting level of Harshad as Abhimanyu is nauseating.....People can't even differentiate whether he is sad or guilty or regret with his expressions....Jay Soni is definitely a better actor as Abhinav because he brought the freshness and innocence to the character Abhinav.

Thank you, for saying that. I was constantly watching AbhiM standing behind his mom. I could not figure out what he was feeling. He was listening to AK's pain with such a stoic face. He can just give red- eyed piercing look. On the other hand, AbhiN just stands out while emoting the subtle feelings. His give and take with others is amazing. His agression fall flat though but that is not even required much for this role.

Sushma_00 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: stunninstar

Jay soni is an amazing actor.. Harshad is a bigger star is what I meant.. as per the fanbase and past work followers.. i am not belittling Jay .. dont take it wrong!

If you have seen KZK you will get what I meant.. Anurag and Prerna the soul couples by shweta tiwari and Cezanne.. If Bajaj was accepted and loved thT was coz of Ronit Roy.. Had it been an actor of lesser reach, i am sure the story would have diverted there..



I dont want thT here.. i want Akshara to never go back and get abused by Manjari.. I want Abhinav to get his dues .. and I want Abhimanyu to repent for the anger he hadZz


Fanbase matters only in social media. TV audience will see the character and the acting of the star.Audience definitely connected with jay Soni/Abhinav. Coming to trp, there is no raise bcoz of the no consistency and context in the current plot. For example, even the truth reveal track not able to fetch trp bcoz the way CVs executed it

stunninstar thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Sushma_Reddy


Fanbase matters only in social media. TV audience will see the character and the acting of the star.Audience definitely connected with jay Soni/Abhinav. Coming to trp, there is no raise bcoz of the no consistency and context in the current plot. For example, even the truth reveal track not able to fetch trp bcoz the way CVs executed it

I disagree that fanbase is strictly to social media! Harshad has a huge fanbase in among audience.. and its not jus that.. his character before the so called “white episode” was in a positive light most of the time.. and the creatives too havent shown him outright negative.. execution is horrible.. creatives themselves dont know what to do.. they cant show Harshad bad.. and neither can they show aarohi the villain as a couple to hero!
firewings_diya thumbnail

Team Abhimanyu (Gen 3)

Posted: 2 years ago
#8

Why trp is not raising

1. The show casted hc but even though they knew hc fans ppl who are born after 90s or before 90s they kept the theme as pyaar ishq mohabbat. I personally do not like themes like this unless the show also has some comedy in it. But i felt there was over dose of romance but story was stagnant that's when i took break from the show. I was expecting focus will be more on healing each others trauma but rather they started with teenage romance sort of drama.i would have loved if they would have taken story like punar vivah instead of blindly following icche node. But i still support harshali as i liked them initially.

2. Drag fest never ending dialogue baazi. Instead of akshu repeating her dialogues multiple times they could revealed it to everyone all at once. And given a promo but in order to have some frama every week akshu is just repeating her dialogues there is nothing fresh. Tomorrow in court also she will repeat yhe same thing what she told to manju. What's the point of making audience listen her story twice.tbh there is nothing left to put out in court drama unless they want to show abhi's pov.

3. Characters stability. Abhi was supportive husbadn all of sudden he became abusive husband. Akshu became selfish in the end of abrohi marriage 1.0 where she accepted abhi infront of every one but she became selfless infront of khera and then she became selfless on that white day.


4. Riding on two boats. No clarity on which ship will sail. Constant fights fd also takes away ppl interest in the show as some ppl want x and some ppl want y. Both keep on arguing ppl who majorly have lot of stress try to avoid this show completely in order avoid getting into social media battles.


5. Fl and ml both needs redemption it's my personal opinion but show just made ml as villain overnight. And expected ppl to accept a new character who is completely good. Tbh when audience knows many characters ruined for one good character it's hard to accept him no matter what he does. As their fav character is ruined overnight to pave a way for a new character. Fls redumption only some minority wants it. But audience may also need her redemption as every family teaches family comes first baaki sab badhme so i am not sure this could be one more reason.


I can remember only these much for now 😄

Edited by firewings_diya - 2 years ago
WhtsinAname thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#9

Jay Soni is actually doing a fab job as Abhinav. The character is well written and he emotes it too well. Its very relatable.

I dnt think Shaheer or any other actor would hv been a better choice for this. Now I am not a Jay Soni fan. But this character demanded to be simple , plain as they come. Abhinav is neither the macho type nor the ruggedly handsome type. The only thing uncommon about this common man is his sense of empathy , his love for people and his selflessness.

That is why I think he was the perfect choice. He isnt a competition to Abhimanyu in looks or style. But he is a better person.


Dts just my opinion.


PS : I am actually a Shaheer fan. But I still dont think he was appropriate to play this role.

Edited by WhtsinAname - 2 years ago
umawanderer thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2

Team Critics

Posted: 2 years ago
#10

I am actually happy that Jay Soni is playing Nav...


If Nav's character was played by any other famous hot actor.. who already have huge fan base.. then the fan wars would have been brutal.. than what it is now😆😆



And besides.. I feel he is doing a really good job now.. I actually like his performance.. He plays the sweet lovable and sensible person in a realistic way.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Tani16 · 1 months ago

Same thing happened in Season 2 when Kairav was traumatized by Naira as she blamed him for Vansh's paralysis and he used to get severe anxiety...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: ritauk · 2 months ago

Why why why is this serial number one? They have repeated the same story in the last 2 generations. I will tell you what will happen…. After...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01 · 2 months ago

So now Abhira adopts somone - Maira gets annoyed resents her... Leap same story again

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Partyc · 3 months ago

1. She was a happy sweet outgoing bubbly girl before Abhir entered her life. 2. Then she fell in love with Abhir but she took a mature decision...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Aleyamma47 · 4 months ago

I had once written in this forum that true meaning of RISHTA can be explored in a different way in Season 5: True meaning of rishta can be...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".