TERE BIN THREAD- EPISODES DISCUSSION ONLY - Page 15

Created

Last reply

Replies

709

Views

123.2k

Users

80

Likes

3.1k

Frequent Posters

JaneAustin thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Sunshinem

I don't think he believes she is really pregnant. Since marriage, he is always in the same room with her and when he goes out to work she stays in the haveli only. If she wants to go out, he takes her. Meerab ki har movement par kabar rakhta hai murtasim. He never lets her out of his sight. She is practically surrounded by him 24/7. How can she get pregnant.. so i don't think he believes that she is pregnant.


Yes I get that too. But it will be a dilemma because MB it’s telling the family and is getting mithai for everyone because of the huge news.
Murtasim will wonder why Meerab didn’t say anything to stop the misunderstanding. He’s not going to tell anyone that it’s food poisoning and she can’t possibly be pregnant as they don’t even sleep together. He will be stressing that the wider public will get to know this news and that it will further embarrass him when it turns out to be false.

He probably can’t talk to Meerab himself because she’s still pissed off with him about Haya and hopefully giving him the silent treatment.
I think he will get angry when he finds out that she’s been with Rohail, but he knows her character well enough to know she’d never sleep with him.

So I think the false pregnancy track will be short lived. I think what will happen is everyone will get to know that she’s not pregnant because they will somehow discover the contract.

MB will be shocked and angry at the humiliation of her son. Anwar, who saw her at the restaurant will wrongly think she is still in love with Rohail and that’s why she wrote the contract. Her parents will secretly agree with him and want to have the chance to support her so will ask her to come back to Karachi with them. And then the separation begins.

Anyway it’s just my thoughts 😆

Edited by JaneAustin - 3 years ago
JaneAustin thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: pressu

I am biased towards Meerab. Meerab deserves so much better. She clearly told that she was getting humiliated because of Haya. I don't understand why it is so difficult for Murtasim to understand this. And also I don't like female leads getting jealous. And I don't like the way Meerab's jealousy is portrayed in a cute and fun way. It is not at all funny.


I totally agree with this. Murtasim has spent the last few days being all romantic and seductive and showing Meerab that he cares for her over and above everyone else. Even telling her to her face that she’s the only one that matters.

And yet she kept telling him that she doesn’t like it when Haya is around him and to not give her any encouragement. He is stupidly thinking that she is jealous and enjoying her annoyance at Haya.

He is not looking at the fact that she is trying to build a relationship with him and that Haya is a huge reason she’s holding back. So finally because of the past few days where he has been so romantic to her, Meerab goes to him to the village with a sense of ‘haq’ only to find out she has been betrayed by him with Haya again. Even if he explains he was trying to help her with a bit of dust in her eye or whatever it was, still the damage is done.

Her tears when she’s shouting at Murtasim are reminiscent of the tears that he shed in the garden when he thought she had left him after the accident. She’s thinking you really don’t care for me at all, your actions prove it.
She is so hurt and I honestly think he deserves to feel what she’s going through when he finds out about her and Rohail.

Edited by JaneAustin - 3 years ago
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 3 years ago

Agree with you.

they have shot whole drama, 🫣🫣🫣 so I don’t think we will see any explanation unless the writer took feedback before finishing her story.

Bcs everyone will have similar question on their mind.


let’s see how they progress then we can give writer a very critical response and to director.
they do read our comments so 👌👌👌

1263643 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Everyone is irritated with the fact that why is Murtasim kind with Haya or talks to her then we must remember that Murtasim confided in Haya about his guilt for the slap. Haya is the girl he grew up with and holds no romantic feelings for but she connected to him and his past, if you remember his conversation with Haya on the staircase, it was very deep and by a glance Haya easily interpreted that he is emotionally connected to Meerab's pain. In that scene as well Murtasim softly asked her to not cry and go to her room. So the softness isn't out of nowhere instead it's realistic for him to be kind with her when he is kind with everyone around. Yes he had been harsh with her initially on her romantic advances but we look deeply so she was never effected from it neither backed away so he changed approach in hopes of changing her and he expressed this to Meerab as well.

We bashed him for about to drink soap from Haya's hand but we forgot that he apologized and never repeated the same mistake even when his one hand was broken and he was on hospital bed.

For sure he shouldn't have taken Haya along but the guy was visibly shaken by the deaths and he refused Anwar as a man was required back at home, Meerab was sick and Maa Begum has her own responsibilities. Murtasim had never entertained Haya's thought and it's clear, he has full confidence on his love for Meerab that he knows that he can never go astray with girls like Haya.

We bashed him for listening to Haya's statements after the accident but we forgot that Murtasim had been insecure and Meerab continuously expressing her dislike for him gave him no reason to trust her at that moment. One has to be an utter fool to trust a girl who insults you left right and center and Murtasim isn't a fool.

We bashed Murtasim for keeping Meerab in dark during Naila's but we didn't acknowledge how his trust was shattered on Meerab after she removed the bullets, he even verbally expressed his disappointment on it but we want him to be head over heals for her, ignoring everything. Even the writer said that because of trust issues Murtasim refrained from confiding in Meerab.

Even than Murtasim apologized but did Meerab apologized too? Noo, even though she should have but she didn't, neither Murtasim ever mentioned her mistakes or made fun of her instead in the latest episode as well he defended her.

It's clear that Allah forgives our mistakes but we as humans considers it obligatory to remember them and defame a person or character.

We are fine with Meerab sharing contract details with rohail because she needed someone to talk with her but we are bashing Murtasim for talking with Haya, even though he always defends Meerab and his marriage in the conversation, whereas Meerab silently listened all the words against Murtasim and didn't even tried to defend him.

Coming to the point of Meerab's insecurities, we forget that Murtasim had been through the same pain of getting caged in the past. He has his own fair share of vulnerabilities and insecurities but just because he don't move around taunting, talking big and being a brat like Meerab, instead tries to act maturely we ignores his pain.

We forget that how traumatic it would be for an emotionally sensitive person like Murtasim to cope with the death of his three men. The scene where he conversed with Haya, we could clearly see the misery in his eyes and how he controlled his tears to stay strong as a feudal. The feudalism wasn't his choice, just like Meerab's marriage wasn't her own choice, but Murtasim agony is far more than Meerab because she always has him at her back and he don't have a genuine companion to share his emotions with, yet he tries his best to deal with the turmoils he has on his own, unlike Meerab who has clearly rejected the idea to accept her reality and faith.

Meerab is vocal about her pain and Murtasim has given his best to share her pain, understand her and be her companion, though he was equally forced in the relationship but till now Meerab has given zero efforts and only caused pain to him emotionally which he always silently forgives without her asking for forgiveness but it's high time that Meerab tries to emotionally understand him if not love him, because relationships can't survive with the effort of one party for too long. Murtasim Khan is vocal about his love but conceals his pain and it nowhere means that he holds none.

Murtasim Khan is a character which which has depth and layers, which only comes on the screen once in a blue moon and if we fails to understand the layers and emotions of that character than I think we nowhere deserves to cry for getting boring, too good to be true characters like Saad and toxic characters like Mir Hadi or Shamsher.

In my eyes Murtasim is neither an angel nor a devil but just a balanced human who has his flaws but what sets him apart is that he accepts them and tries to be better, but as I mentioned earlier that we as viewers never considers the option of forgiveness.

FireSafireFiree thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 3 years ago

Well said.

I think most people r ignoring this man going through.

1. 3 men’s death

2. Lack of love from his wife

3. Worried haya might do something stupid like killing her self.

4. His wife is actually not feeling well

5. Someone need to stay home

6. His mum is old!


however writer could have showed taking haya with him in another plot. Bcs it didn’t fit in well this time. it wasn’t coherent.


also I think Bcs of time slot and stuff the director couldn’t show every scene that was written. There are many stuff missing or I will blame the editing sectors.

It is important to show some small stuff to make the story move smoothly.
most people probably want to see meerab and murtasam so they forget other characters feeling and I think there was something lacking to highlight importance of some character. Like the death of three men!! Bru most people just ignored that 🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️


so idk if that’s the way story progressed or the way they shot!!
this Malik’s son is dangerous



spnfan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Most Posts (July 2022) Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Slender-Rose123

Everyone is irritated with the fact that why is Murtasim kind with Haya or talks to her then we must remember that Murtasim confided in Haya about his guilt for the slap. Haya is the girl he grew up with and holds no romantic feelings for but she connected to him and his past, if you remember his conversation with Haya on the staircase, it was very deep and by a glance Haya easily interpreted that he is emotionally connected to Meerab's pain. In that scene as well Murtasim softly asked her to not cry and go to her room. So the softness isn't out of nowhere instead it's realistic for him to be kind with her when he is kind with everyone around. Yes he had been harsh with her initially on her romantic advances but we look deeply so she was never effected from it neither backed away so he changed approach in hopes of changing her and he expressed this to Meerab as well.

We bashed him for about to drink soap from Haya's hand but we forgot that he apologized and never repeated the same mistake even when his one hand was broken and he was on hospital bed.

For sure he shouldn't have taken Haya along but the guy was visibly shaken by the deaths and he refused Anwar as a man was required back at home, Meerab was sick and Maa Begum has her own responsibilities. Murtasim had never entertained Haya's thought and it's clear, he has full confidence on his love for Meerab that he knows that he can never go astray with girls like Haya.

We bashed him for listening to Haya's statements after the accident but we forgot that Murtasim had been insecure and Meerab continuously expressing her dislike for him gave him no reason to trust her at that moment. One has to be an utter fool to trust a girl who insults you left right and center and Murtasim isn't a fool.

We bashed Murtasim for keeping Meerab in dark during Naila's but we didn't acknowledge how his trust was shattered on Meerab after she removed the bullets, he even verbally expressed his disappointment on it but we want him to be head over heals for her, ignoring everything. Even the writer said that because of trust issues Murtasim refrained from confiding in Meerab.

Even than Murtasim apologized but did Meerab apologized too? Noo, even though she should have but she didn't, neither Murtasim ever mentioned her mistakes or made fun of her instead in the latest episode as well he defended her.

It's clear that Allah forgives our mistakes but we as humans considers it obligatory to remember them and defame a person or character.

We are fine with Meerab sharing contract details with rohail because she needed someone to talk with her but we are bashing Murtasim for talking with Haya, even though he always defends Meerab and his marriage in the conversation, whereas Meerab silently listened all the words against Murtasim and didn't even tried to defend him.

Coming to the point of Meerab's insecurities, we forget that Murtasim had been through the same pain of getting caged in the past. He has his own fair share of vulnerabilities and insecurities but just because he don't move around taunting, talking big and being a brat like Meerab, instead tries to act maturely we ignores his pain.

We forget that how traumatic it would be for an emotionally sensitive person like Murtasim to cope with the death of his three men. The scene where he conversed with Haya, we could clearly see the misery in his eyes and how he controlled his tears to stay strong as a feudal. The feudalism wasn't his choice, just like Meerab's marriage wasn't her own choice, but Murtasim agony is far more than Meerab because she always has him at her back and he don't have a genuine companion to share his emotions with, yet he tries his best to deal with the turmoils he has on his own, unlike Meerab who has clearly rejected the idea to accept her reality and faith.

Meerab is vocal about her pain and Murtasim has given his best to share her pain, understand her and be her companion, though he was equally forced in the relationship but till now Meerab has given zero efforts and only caused pain to him emotionally which he always silently forgives without her asking for forgiveness but it's high time that Meerab tries to emotionally understand him if not love him, because relationships can't survive with the effort of one party for too long. Murtasim Khan is vocal about his love but conceals his pain and it nowhere means that he holds none.

Murtasim Khan is a character which which has depth and layers, which only comes on the screen once in a blue moon and if we fails to understand the layers and emotions of that character than I think we nowhere deserves to cry for getting boring, too good to be true characters like Saad and toxic characters like Mir Hadi or Shamsher.

In my eyes Murtasim is neither an angel nor a devil but just a balanced human who has his flaws but what sets him apart is that he accepts them and tries to be better, but as I mentioned earlier that we as viewers never considers the option of forgiveness.

Murtasim's softness towards haya could have been justified if he was a soft person in general but he is the guy that took firm stand for meerab and even threatened his own mother for her when his mother had valid reasons to be harsh on meerab according to her pov. But when it comes to behaya he is so sympathetic that he don't care his wife don't like behaya roaming around him and feels insecure.

He himself saw behaya wearing the gajra he bought for meerab and flaunting it in from of meerab but all he did was keep his mouth shut in front of behaya. How can anything justify that. He is not taking any stern stand against behaya. He could simply say her to shut up about meerab and never to bad mouth about his wife in front of him. If he can take strong stand for meerab against his mother what's stopping him from taking a strong stand against haya who repeatedly made everyone know her intentions?

Whatever happened to murtasim happened years ago and he had time to cop with it and move on and meerab is completely unaware of it. Him having to leave a lifestyle oppose to what he dreamt of can never be equal to meerab finding out her parentage truth and her foster parents not opening the door for her. Everything meerab went through has been witnessed by murtasim. We never saw how murtasim behaved in the first few months of being forced into this type of life. We don't even know if that is even the real matter. All of this are just assumptions whereas we know what meerab actually went through and how her entirely life has been turned upside down.

Nobody is fine with meerab sharing contract details with rohail. Rohail has not yet forced his feelings on meerab the way behaya has been doing since ep 1. So meerab being comfortable around rohail is understandable. Meerab spilling out the contract to rohail is a stupid and dumb move but she isn't aware of rohail's level of obsession with her whereas murtasim, maa begum, mariyam and meerab are perfectly aware of how obsessed haya is with murtasim and still she is being allowed to spend 2-3 days alone with murtasim at the village. This is the same family that created a huge scene when meerab simply danced at the wedding. Now they are sending a young unmarried woman to look after a married man whom she is in love with. How does anything about this makes sense.

Rohail has a solid reason to dislike murtasim even if we forget about his obsession with meerab. He misbehaved with rohail at his own party for no apparent reasons. So meerab can give a blind eye to rohail's dislike for murtasim. Even if rohail was a good guy and didn't had romantic feelings for meerab, he would have still disliked murtasim. Why is murtasim repeatedly giving a blind eye to behaya's hate speech for meerab. It has been happening for 3-4 times now and he simply sits there and gives some lame excuse. He don't even try to change the topic. He also knows the exact reason why behaya hates meerab.

@bold humza from mere Humsafar was neither boring like saad nor toxic to the level like Mir Hadi, the male leads from chupke chupke or suno Chanda were also neither boring nor toxic. All these are dramas that did really well. The ML from parizaad didn't even have the good looks or swag but still made everyone root for him.

Everyone remembers zaroon Junaid and liked him with all his flaws because he is a well written character with layers and depth. If people are not able to understand why murtasim is acting the way he is then the fault lies in the writing and not with the audience. It's the same audience that has been making the drama and wahaj treat on social media since the start of the drama. It's not like murtasim or tere bin is a masterpiece that is being rejected by the audience. The drama is getting way more love that it deserves simply because audience are attracted to the leads and their chemistry. So why balme the audience for not accepting the stupidity served to us rather than pointing out faulty writing.

FieryLioness thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 3 years ago

Thanks Sera🤗 ... it was much needed I feel😳


2 episodes more.. one was complete fun nd light hearted and 2nd was just classic example of poor writing. I think haya is the only character, writer has managed to maintaine consistency. She is same from episode one. Baki sab to rab hi jane


Episode 23rd was good with all meerasim moments. This is the kind of episode I would watch again skipping the haya scenes 😆

Nd 24th was though important to move story forward but miserably failed with all major characters (MB, murtasim and meerab) behaving opposite to their characters...

Starting with MB nd murtasim, I am not able to understand why they are ignoring Haya's behavior. This is just not right... this cousin trash is going bit far... nd how shamelessly haya is confessing her love again nd again, And murtasim is just taking it lightly as if it is no big deal. They are from conservative setup . How come they are even allowing haya near him.. really disappointed in murtasim for this.

Nd for meerab, the less said the better... I'll not go into what made her confide into Rohail. But least she could do, defend murtasim when Rohail was bad mouthing about him. Murtasim hasn't done anything wrong to meerab that she can't even take his stand. On other side we hv seen enough of murtasim defending meerab, be it in her presence or when she is not around.. I expected better from meerab there... basically she told Rohail the things she feel and not the truth.

And for pregnancy MU, the same meerab can stand up to any body, insult the elders but couldn't tell the truth. Even when they declared to reveal it to whole khandan, then too she didn't clear this misunderstanding. So one more humiliation coming up for murtasim. Honestly guy doesn't deserve so much humiliation for no fault of his..

Next episode going to be more misunderstandings..

Also high time they get separated for some time cause no matter what murtasim does to make this marriage work, meerab is in her zone nd she is not ready to accept him... so she needs that break from him nd went back to her original set up... if that's what makes her happy..

arshi1983 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 3 years ago

My 2 cents-


"It's pretty obvious that the only thing the makers spend any time on is to have intense passionate scenes and tashan scenes between meerab and murtasim. Everything else is just there. Even pak daily soaps put more effort in establishing the characters than this drama with A list actors and high production quality" ---- I beg to differ here!

In a finite series, u cannot crowd ur script with too many scenes that keeps establishing the characters and their arcs. A recent example- In PS1, Mani sir would've just established the character of kundavai in 1-2 scenes, so as a viewer u just a catch that little thread and travel along and try to understand her subsequent actions. IMO, feeding too much to the audience is a thing of the past;catch their nuances and meet them in the middle.


Thanks for saying this-

Everyone is irritated with the fact that why is Murtasim kind with Haya or talks to her then we must remember that Murtasim confided in Haya about his guilt for the slap. Haya is the girl he grew up with and holds no romantic feelings for but she connected to him and his past, if you remember his conversation with Haya on the staircase, it was very deep and by a glance Haya easily interpreted that he is emotionally connected to Meerab's pain. In that scene as well Murtasim softly asked her to not cry and go to her room. So the softness isn't out of nowhere instead it's realistic for him to be kind with her when he is kind with everyone around. Yes he had been harsh with her initially on her romantic advances but we look deeply so she was never effected from it neither backed away so he changed approach in hopes of changing her and he expressed this to Meerab as well.

They've shared a good camaraderie in the past and there were a couple of scenes to establish that. The times when he whisked her hand away were the ones where she was obviously making some physical advances and nudging him to accept her love. The reason for him not being all macho or the quintessential feudal lord in the Panchayat was because he was visibly shaken with what had happened to those 3 guys. He is beginning to question his decisions! He said "Hum in ghareebon ki qismat kiu apne hathon se likh dete hain" ---this introspection is again a character development! He feels he is responsible for ruining Naila's life. He is learning too. He is a flawed human afterall! If he doesnt change even after Meerab's outburt in the enxt episode, then I will change my stance. But atleast up until now, I see no character glitches!

Edited by arshi1983 - 3 years ago
arshi1983 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 3 years ago

IMO, Zaroon Junaid is a toxic character It was supposedly charismatic for a few because Fawad played it otherwise there was nothing remotely attractive about his character.

zooni.blue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: madhuvan


I am not surprised by this.

this is the difference between "Ghar Ki Beti" and "Bahu"


Even Murtasim will defend all crimes of Haya cause she is there ghar ki beti , and if Meerab does mistake she will have to prove her innocence

Ghar ki beti or not this is unacceptable behavior in pak shows I have seen...writer is taking too many liberties here

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".