Diljit Dosanjh says 1984 was a genocide and not riots - Page 2

Originally posted by: Grumpydwarf24

Is this film about partition ?

not talking about the film, but the real mass murders and historical worst possible human killings that happened by the same community during 1947 partition (darkest pages of history of south Asian region), who got genocide in 1984

Originally posted by: semantic.error

Is there a trailer for this? I highly doubt Ali Abbas Zafar of all people has the sensitivity to handle this well.

His films always have decent stories

Originally posted by: kingkhan22

not talking about the film, but the real mass murders and historical worst possible human killings that happened by the same community during 1947 partition (darkest pages of history of south Asian region), who got genocide in 1984

Right so you are saying if a community does something bad once. They must have been at fault all the time ???

Originally posted by: Grumpydwarf24

Right so you are saying if a community does something bad once. They must have been at fault all the time ???

NOPE

just recalling the facts about the "victims"

Originally posted by: kingkhan22

NOPE

just recalling the facts about the "victims"

What happened during partition will not change the fact that 1984 was a genocide? And those who suffered from it were survivors and martyrs. I don’t recall anyone using the term victim here besides you?

Just so you know the violence of partition fell more heavily on Punjab. As that was one major state being divided. It didn’t mean people from all faiths, caste, creed, from both countries and other states in those countries didn’t participate.

Originally posted by: Grumpydwarf24

What happened during partition will not change the fact that 1984 was a genocide? And those who suffered from it were survivors and martyrs. I don’t recall anyone using the term victim here besides you?

ok

answer my question

u still have not

was 1947 partition killing a genocide or not?

still waiting for your answer, just for this simple question without involving 1984

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/06/29/the-great-divide-books-dalrymple

Originally posted by: kingkhan22

ok

answer my question

u still have not

was 1947 partition killing a genocide or not?

still waiting for your answer, just for this simple question without involving 1984

I am still not sure why partition is relevant in discussion about a film about 1984 ? But partition involved mob violence of all kinds of people who lived in the two countries being divided.

Originally posted by: Grumpydwarf24

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/06/29/the-great-divide-books-dalrymple

have you heard about the phrase "aatay may namak kay barabar" ?

I rest my case here.