Meray Humsafar[ARY]|Thread #2|Farhan Saeed, Hania Aamir - Page 36

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

46.9k

Users

27

Likes

2.1k

Frequent Posters

The_Imane thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: .Dilwale.

This is why I enjoy forums which are not dominated by fangirls. It’s much more fun to discuss the show that way. Because fans will never see or think beyond their fav’s character.


IMO Sameen is not a good person despite being so educated. Remind me if I am wrong but we never saw her defend or protect Hala from all the abuse she was put through happening right in front of her eyes. And she treated her terribly after Hamza married Hala instead of her. Insulting her, vandalising her room, getting physical with her. Even when Hala fainted right in front of her eyes, she didn’t even move a muscle. Is that what being educated means? Because otherwise she even lacks basic ethics.

And I also thought I was the only one who noticed that Hala seemed sick while climbing the stairs to Khurram’s apartment. I guess that got lost between all the Hala bashing lol. I now foresee Khurram as Hala’s well wisher in the coming episodes, as he will realise after this incident how Shahjahan was playing both him and Hala from the very beginning to suit her evil agendas.

The writing is inconsistent and terrible atm because both the writer/director have only one purpose in mind. To salvage Hamza. The rest be damned. People were loving Hala’s progression so much and they ruined it just for the sake of sensationalism. Obviously it backfired. The show is degrading in quality day by day. Look at how the views and trp have decreased.


@Italic Yes, I think I remember you from somewhere before too ? :)

Twitter is toxic as a platform itself, on each topic. Its more about the hashtag and people saying what get likes and RT, not really real depthful discussions. I have seen a few threads since the begining of the show on MH that were deep and good but they get little likes and attention, the whole platform is for buzz and drama.

@Bold Yeah, I dont at all feel sorry for Sameen. She was so toxic about Hamza, physically hurt Hala, even if Hala has always been nice to her, even nicer than she is to Rumi. Hala also felt like she was a bit complexed with Sameen, not anymore and that's good. To me, I liked Sameen episode 1-10, then they wanted so bad to make a triangle / deceived girl situation that they ruined her whole character. So idc for her that much. Hala genuinely does, however, and its what will cost her.

@underlined I agree with you, even if him being nicer to her might worsen Hamza's missunderstanding, but its a mature way of handling things - we had a relationship, it didnt work, lets move on. And yes, it does help realise that SJ has been lying since the start and purposely ruined it all for them, even if Khurram's still at fault. It might help in the end too because SJ herself has admitted to Raees how she lied to Khurram about Hala-Hamza being engaged.

@bold italic I agree completely. They took the "nice hero" thing so far, in a comlete 180 degrees turn from Asher (Humsafar) that they ruined Hala's character developpement, when the story was clearly initially hers. It was about her for 7-8 entire episodes, was about her evolving and growing from her trauma in the begining of their marriage... Now they've kind of messed it all up, this is why I'd rather they didn't modify a story once its written, it ruins it and make it a headache. They better have a really good epilogue/end in store, that could make up for the mess and inconsistency of episodes 20-28.



I really want Shafaq back in the picture btw, she was such a genuinely nice friend & support system for Hala, and reacted much better than Sameen even if it was worst for her because Khurram & her actually were committed unlike Hamza and Sameen.

Sera-high123 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

https://youtu.be/6o-K6YmW258


Watch from 50:30. The way these guys have bashed Mere Humsafar 😆😆

xZoyax thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: 18shabbo

Watching desi shows is tough, feelings, perception aur time sabka kachra hojata hai aur milta kuch nhi 🥺we can only discuss/vent out.

But it is also a time passing way too.

When it derails and goes my nerves to make me feel going on emotional and attachment track, then I just leave and see the end to get the point of what actually happened.😆 but yes,most of the time just Kachra at the end.

.Dilwale. thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Sera-high123

https://youtu.be/6o-K6YmW258


Watch from 50:30. The way these guys have bashed Mere Humsafar 😆😆


I have always found Hassan a better critic than Amina somehow. Amina is extremely biased and inconsistent in her reviews. Yahan tu aise lag raha hai jaise saari ghalti bus Hania ki he hai rofl. Writer se ziyada Hania ka kasoor. Director se ziyada Hania ka kasoor. Found her a bit disrespectful towards Hania tbh. Considering that she relentlessly defended one toxic Feroz Khan character after another never calling him out for his script choices 😂

Smudge thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: .Dilwale.


I have always found Hassan a better critic than Amina somehow. Amina is extremely biased and inconsistent in her reviews. Yahan tu aise lag raha hai jaise saari ghalti bus Hania ki he hai rofl. Writer se ziyada Hania ka kasoor. Director se ziyada Hania ka kasoor. Found her a bit disrespectful towards Hania tbh. Considering that she relentlessly defended one toxic Feroz Khan character after another never calling him out for his script choices 😂

Lol we were bashing Amna in the sang e mah thread due to her being biased towards Feroze and disrespectful towards Danish Taimoor whereas in reality Danish is much better than her fav.She has some kind of problem with few actors and flip flops like anything.I remember in parde main rehne do ivs she was buttering Hania so much when in reality in her review she was openly discussing about her facial surgeries,heck i found that way too disrespectful.I was shocked seeing her change like that,like in her review she was being so disrespectful to that person and when came face to face,she changed her attitude altogether and was praising her non stop..I find Hassan atleast a bit better than her.

Sera-high123 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: .Dilwale.


I have always found Hassan a better critic than Amina somehow. Amina is extremely biased and inconsistent in her reviews. Yahan tu aise lag raha hai jaise saari ghalti bus Hania ki he hai rofl. Writer se ziyada Hania ka kasoor. Director se ziyada Hania ka kasoor. Found her a bit disrespectful towards Hania tbh. Considering that she relentlessly defended one toxic Feroz Khan character after another never calling him out for his script choices 😂


Oh definitely Amina went overboard with her criticism for Hania. She has taken a U-turn in this matter though I have seen her praising both Hania and Farhan and the show Mere Humsafar......... calling it a beautiful story with great performances and suddenly when the views have become less the story isn't worthy of being nominated and that she has lost respect for actors for doing the show🤪

We all are dissapointed by the script at this moment but we can't take away actor's performances when they all have been really good.

Edited by Sera-high123 - 3 years ago
Smudge thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Sera-high123

https://youtu.be/6o-K6YmW258


Watch from 50:30. The way these guys have bashed Mere Humsafar 😆😆

This time i agree with their review.But i dont get the uproar of MH copying Humsafar😔..Humsafar was not the maiden show who has a copyright over such track,heck i have seen this track on itv again and again.Just because the show’s name is similar to Humsafar,it is getting highlighted again and again,if the name was not identical with Humsafar nobody would have even lifted a finger and thought about the show’s similarity..

And Hania being responsible for signing this show up,yup she is to some extent but an actor can not do anything if there are new scenes included which was not supposed to be there in the first place but being shot later on when the show is already in midway where the actor has no other choice but to continue ,if she does not want to breach her contract and have a bad name in her career.Also Hania is being bashed more often than not for being only able to do one certain type of character that is bubbly roles so i guess through this show and SeM she wanted to prove her versatility and shut their mouth off.And comparing her with Saba or Mehwish doesnt make semse,because they are way more senior than her and it is not like in their earlier stage of their career they didmt take up bad decision on their scripts and characters..

Sera-high123 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Smithhh

This time i agree with their review.But i dont get the uproar of MH copying Humsafar😔..Humsafar was not the maiden show who has a copyright over such track,heck i have seen this track on itv again and again.Just because the show’s name is similar to Humsafar,it is getting highlighted again and again,if the name was not identical with Humsafar nobody would have even lifted a finger and thought about the show’s similarity..

And Hania being responsible for signing this show up,yup she is to some extent but an actor can not do anything if there are new scenes included which was not supposed to be there in the first place but being shot later on when the show is already in midway where the actor has no other choice but to continue ,if she does not want to breach her contract and have a bad name in her career.Also Hania is being bashed more often than not for being only able to do one certain type of character that is bubbly roles so i guess through this show and SeM she wanted to prove her versatility and shut their mouth off.And comparing her with Saba or Mehwish doesnt make semse,because they are way more senior than her and it is not like in their earlier stage of their career they didmt take up bad decision on their scripts and characters..


I agree with plotholes they are pointing out with respect to Khurram and Hala's character but this constant comparison to Humsafar is so not done. Its not like this is the first show where we have seen a scene like this.

Also, even though I really like Fawad Mahira and was in love with the first half of Humsafar and their chemistry........even Humsafar story wasn't original. The misunderstanding and doubting your spouse storyline has been done nth time upto that point.

Smudge thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Sera-high123


Oh definitely Amina went overboard with her criticism for Hania. She has taken a U-turn in this matter though I have seen her praising both Hania and Farhan and the show Mere Humsafar......... calling it a beautiful story with great performances and suddenly when the views have become less the story isn't worthy of being nominated and that she has lost respect for actors for doing the show🤪

We all are dissapointed by the script at this moment but we can't take away actor's performances where they all have been really good.

Gosh the way she flip flops you wont even believe😆...Tell me one thing if they were so disappointed then what the hell in the mid of their thumbnail Hala is doing or why their first headline consists of Mere Humsafar or Humsafar🤪..When the show and the characters pisses you off so much why are you posting them on thumbnail and even your headline is about the show😲..Like attention aur views bhi grab karna hai aur yeh bhi show karna hai arre yeh show is not upto my standard and all..I despise this kind of hypocrisy..

Edited by Smithhh - 3 years ago
Sera-high123 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Smithhh

Gosh the way she flip flops you wont even believe😆...Tell me one thing if they were so disappointed then what the hell in the mid of their thumbnail Hala is doing or why their first headline consists of Mere Humsafar or Humsafar🤪..When the show and the characters pisses you off so much why are you posting them on thumbnail and even your headline is about the show😲..Like attention aur views bhi grab karna hai aur yeh bhi show karna hai arre yeh show is not upto my standard and all..I despise this kind of hypocrisy..


I mean when the TRP was high and the show was getting 20 M views the praises were so high for this show...........calling it a sweet little fairytale with amazing chemistry and great performances and now suddenly they are questioning the actors choices ti take up this show? 🤪

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".