Maddam Sir - EDT #2 - Page 30

Originally posted by: Chir-Cute

@bold: This is legit the only part of that sequence that made me really pleased. For once, Pushpa ji did not aggravate the matter and took the right decision instead of keeping on with her blind faith.

Santu and Pushpa Ji standing against HM suddenly reminded me of thana competition where entire MPT was at one side and Haseena was standing at the other, firm with her virtues and principles. Perhaps that was the first time Pushpa Ji stood against Haseena and I clearly remember, out of all people it was Pushpa Ji lies that has hurt Haseena the most. That time my heart clenched for Haseena and at the same time I was so damn proud of her.

How fast the night changes. On Saturday, it was again Haseena standing alone but the only difference was this time Haseena was facing consequences of her own messed up reasonings and actions. This time I didn't feel anything for her because she was the only one who was at fault.

I wonder what changed between these two episodes that Haseena is no more the same. I don't even find traces of that Haseena now.

Sometimes I so wish Haseena loses this competition and MPT. Somehow MPT has become her weakness and the very thought of losing it has taken emotional turmoil over her. Perhaps it was fear on staining MPT's reputation that she lost it completely and didn't even cared to listen to Karishma, or even Pushpa Ji and Santu. She seriously needs break from MPT so that she gets time to sort out her mind. Anyways she was sent here because MPT was drowning and someone needed to save it. She did her job and undoubtedly she did it best. Today MPT is best station present in the city . So her job is complete. All the officers have come a long way under her leadership and they are best version of themselves now. They don't need her anymore

And cherry on the cake they have Amar now who can very well guide MPT further. Going away from MPT will give her time to think over her life and then she can take incharge of any new station. Might be then my Haseena will be back to her older self. And I so badly need her back

I remember Ayanti's words that Haseena Mallik was a miracle. Sad part is was

Originally posted by: Chir-Cute

All I gotta say in regards to Saturday's episode is that once upon a time Haseena had said, "Jab baat wardi ki izzat ki ho toh hum jazbaat nahi dekhte. Iss wardi ko koi chu bhi nahi sakta" - Epi 43

and they completely contradicted her.

I was genuinely worried about KarEena tashan in the sense that lines of decency and professionalism should not be crossed in the argument and exactly that happened. The brilliance of this argument is seen in the precap where Haseena is outrageously accusing her MPT of betrayal. 👏👏👏

Haseena's character arc has completely deflected after Urmi's arrival. She is no longer the same Haseena I was fond of. Urmi took that Haseena away and left traces of herself behind.

Santu and PJ looked quite disappointed in HM for a change. I am already mad at HM for her accusations but I will be even madder at writers if the writers give her the ghatiya lines, "Hume yeh pata nahi tha. Apne hume puri baat batayi kyun nahi...Hume maaf kardijiye" etc etc, Bahen, aap ne unhe bolne ka mauka hi kaha diya? App toh bomb ki traha fatt padi PJ pe bhi when she was trying to tell you what exactly had happened.

Some people hypothesised that this is HM's plan to find the real traitor and verify Amar probably (I was also one of them) but even then scolding an SI in front of a civilian and the competitors and junior staff is always uncalled for.

Anyway, let's see what happens today...

@Bold: In order to do a 360 degree change and bring out various shades into their lead character, perhaps writers themselves didn't realize that the extent to which they changed Haseena that I don't find the existence of concept of show anymore.

Now I know what Anubhav fans might have felt when he was announced traitor just withing 2 episodes.

@Orange: I can bet this is not an act. This is the takraar audience we're demanding since Amar's entry. And I can actually see major section of audience happy with this new track because they got their so called Kareena tashan back

Ok, so for context, I'm new to the fandom, and rinki has been helping me binge through madam sir. Anyway, I've just finished watching episode 513, AND OH MY LIFE THIS EPISODE WAS SO PAINFUL TO WATCH.

Why is Haseena so pressed on pleasing the parents??? what exactly do Karishma's stunts have anything to do with being morally correct???? like oh my life, miss gurl if you want to be soooooo morally correct, why don't you arrest the parents for letting other kids ride a motorbike??? It's illegal and isn't it your job to arrest people disobeying the law? Why must Haseena be so desperate to pai1 ma3 pi4 the parents?

Like for real, I can't be the only one who thinks Karishma is 100% innocent in this episode, she should not be responsible for the idiotic actions of kids and negligent parents. At this point, it just seems that the writers are very desperate to constantly make Haseena in the right, and it's super freaking annoying :/

OK , should Haseena be informed about the other SHO who is working in the station by Karishma? is this part of her duty? has Karishma been appointed as a spy in the station? I am still unable to understand the actual reason of her being upset with Karishma, was she upset because she was not informed about AV and KS's meeting with DSP sir? Was she upset about that violence thing? If she was upset about that road thing then what about her line "agar baat wardi ki ho toh hum jazbaat nahi dekhte"

and where is the logic in saying "humne vo dhokhebaaz wali baat Karishma Singh ko nahi boli thi" how can she justify this? matlab she was scolding Karishma but out of nowhere she started using the words like "dhokhebaaz" "mukhbili (if I am not wrong then this was the word)" and all, if she was not saying this to Karishma then kisko bol rahi thien? and why did she not clarify when Karishma was going from there?

are makers obsessed with something? why are they so desperate to prove Haseena right always? and my biggest question, rather doubt is whether Haseena realize her mistake (I am asking this)?

Originally posted by: Rice_Bucket1804

Ok, so for context, I'm new to the fandom, and rinki has been helping me binge through madam sir. Anyway, I've just finished watching episode 513, AND OH MY LIFE THIS EPISODE WAS SO PAINFUL TO WATCH.

Why is Haseena so pressed on pleasing the parents??? what exactly do Karishma's stunts have anything to do with being morally correct???? like oh my life, miss gurl if you want to be soooooo morally correct, why don't you arrest the parents for letting other kids ride a motorbike??? It's illegal and isn't it your job to arrest people disobeying the law? Why must Haseena be so desperate to pai1 ma3 pi4 the parents?

Like for real, I can't be the only one who thinks Karishma is 100% innocent in this episode, she should not be responsible for the idiotic actions of kids and negligent parents. At this point, it just seems that the writers are very desperate to constantly make Haseena in the right, and it's super freaking annoying :/

Adding on to this rant, I'm at Ep 514, and Haseena keeps saying "This (arresting the criminals) is true heroism Karishma" Like, WOMAN ARE U STUPID??? Karishma was NEVER trying to be heroic by doing that motorbike stunt, she was doing it to catch the criminals.
Oh my life I swear it's because of dumb people like Haseena is why shampoo bottles still have instructions on them

I haven't been active on IF because firstly, I am short of time and secondly the episodes are boring which makes me want to rant more than discuss. i wasn't going to post this today either but damn did the last couple of episodes suck out all ounce of my forbearance.

before I say anything, I would like to apologise in advance to all the haseena stans especially komal because I know you love haseena as much as I love my masumiyat.

1) even though it is frustrating to see the montu get away with the drug smuggling thing, I understand why Pushpa Ji wouldn't want him to go to juvie. firstly, she is Pushpa Ji, counselling in charge, a naturally compassionate and soft-hearted person, naive even. on top of it all, she is a mother of 6 six- there has to be some form of natural maternal/protective instincts that come from that experience/role- the way she insisted of the same from Karishma as her mother-in-law is evidence enough. of course, she wouldn't want to see a promising child such as montu, who given the right guidance and support, can have a bright future, and waste his life away in juvie.

the child, montu, I don't excuse him for what he did. it was wrong on so many levels and Pushpa Ji should have had a word with him (a much more serious one than the 1-minute cheesy case resolution scene. the lack of any emotional weight these things carry through is nauseating.). But, I do sympathise with him. the way his father so blatantly stated that he doesn't care about his own son is bound the scar the child for life. the feeling of abandonment, hurt and anger can leave imprints on a child's mind that would eventually catch up to him in adulthood no matter how much he tries to suppress it (evident from when he simply ignored his father and left the station.). it could be my own bias stemming from the fact that I am an ECDE student and thus, childhood trauma/damage/bad early years experiences are my trigger points. in some, if not many ways, the kid isn't completely to blame for this mess. as Karishma said, no good son deserves a shitty father like mangal singh.

2) I don't have much to say about Amar because the writers themselves don't know what they want him to be. other than triggering maddam malik and bringing out her most off-putting qualities, I cant see a purpose for him from a storytelling point of view. of course, there is the mystery of his past and insecurities that can and should be explored but again, I don't see how it's impacting the storyline. yes, he is a good representation of respectable males in society who bring with them their own set of struggles. i appreciate that but what next?

ill edit this later.

that was such a low blow on diwaan ji's end. I am glad amar reprimanded him.

Monday's episode;

Deewan ji 🤦 aap ka kya karu main?

Glad Amar was against HS's actions

Why is his sister returning 😡

Just because it's the aniversary of JPT , they're doing a part 3 of it ( part 2 was HM vs AV)

HM's reasoning is stupid, Amar and KS might've met DSP for case related stuff , why should she tell every little detail to Haseena? And this is not a reason to call someone as "Dhokebaaz"

Eventhough Pushpaji took Karishma 's side she's making KS understand through HM'S pov , alteast tell them both about the praises they said about her behind their back or atleast clearly explain what happened to HM before trying to pacify anyone....

Yesterday's Episode;

Didn't watch , just watched the precap , I'm done with this show....

So, I've finally reached ep 516, and I swear to God the writers were drunk when writing this plot.

Amar is such a confusing character. His motivations and beliefs are so conflicting, and it's not just him that's conflicting, but basically, everyone else who is against the Mahila Police Thana.

One thing I've always liked about this show is that the way they approached Feminism, it was never female > male, they were able to exemplify true feminism, which is female=male, and how men also face problems under the patriarchy. I will admit, the show still has its flaws when it comes to this, but honestly, overall I'd say it's still quite good.

Now, all of a sudden, the DSP starts spouting nonsense like "Men can go to Amar's station, and women can go to yours (Mahila police thana)" LIKE BRO WHAT??? The Mahila police thana has taken up so many cases either from men or involving men as well, so what exactly is the logic behind DSP making that statement?? Did the writers forget they wrote about the many cases that came in from men?????

Then, we move on to Amar, Oh my life where do I even begin... You'd think he'd be MUCH better than Anubhav, he's nice, supposedly respects women, supports feminism, is great with kids etc, I low-key thought he would become a mary-sue of sorts. But this went downhill pretty darn quickly.

Firstly, he says 'Sir, the Women's police station is not necessary" and that when he "Takes over', "All the women will gain my trust" Like bro what are you on?? Does he forget that in situations such as SA, women may feel more comfortable around other women than men??

Then, he starts acting like he's the victim, saying "men are always sidelined" LIKE BRUH. Look, I know I said, yes feminism means male=female, but honestly, in this situation we all know women are the ones getting discriminated in this case, considering the fact that women are discriminated against in the workforce, and the show demonstrates this as well (e.g. Bubul Pandey's team always looking down on the Mahila police thana).

AND THE OTHER POINT HE MADE OH MY LIFE I WANTED TO BANG MY HEAD AGAINST THE WALL. "Women can't handle hardcore cases' Amar, my dude, do you have any idea who in the world you are talking to, they took down so many terrorists. LIKE BRO HOW IN THE WORLD U CONSIDER URSELF A FEMINIST BUT LOOK DOWN ON WOMEN AT THE SMAE TIME.
Honestly, if Amar's mother gave birth to a piece of char siu ( BBQ pork), the char siu would be more feminist than Amar.

And can I also just say, when Amar said "You're not madam sir, just madam because I am the sir" I cringed all the way into my intestines.

Originally posted by: LogicLover

There was a time when she actually had very sharp cop skills. Her observation skills, her analytical skills and her skill to connect the dots were one of the main reasons I had fallen for her so hard, of course alongwith her virtues and command over her emotions but sadly she doesn't have any of them now.

Haseena had it initially and Amar has it now. Sometimes Amar seems so much like Haseena from initial episodes, if we forget the emotions and her experience

Yea in retrospect, you're right. HM did have those observation and analysis skills. I think I'm getting super biased against her lately, because 1.its been long since we've seen her sharp mind, 2.she has stupidly jumped into dangerous situations so many times now, that its hard to imagine her as a brilliant cop anymore, 3.she has been behaving weirder and weirder that there is no real character anymore

The more I see old episodes the more I fall for her values, determination and unflinching display of civility/respect. Seeing her current version, in contrast to the old, makes me more and more frustrated. She has none of that now.

Totally agree about Amar being like old Haseena, I have felt that too. They made him say that out-of-character dialogue about violence just to compare him with KS. Otherwise, I've found him to be smart, cool, collected, minding his own business like old Haseena.