I rewatched the first ep, and I think Ushna was flattered by his praise and gift. She probably had good feelings for him since he's always been nice to her, and they're cousins. Maybe she was thinking who knows what the future holds, but he's a sweet guy that she'd be okay with. This is a dumb example, but it's kinda like, it would be nice to eat fries for dinner tonight, but if I don't, it's not a big deal either. Those are the kinda vibes I get that Ushna feels for Sufiyan.
I feel like she's kinda indirect because that's what she really feels. Like you said, she doesn't really care who she married in the end, as long as it's Zainab's choice. I think when her feelings for Shehroz gets stronger, she'll have a more firm rejection for Sufiyan (even if he'll never listen to her).
I don't think she'll be able to have the same bond that she shares with Shehroz. Even if she made an effort with Sufiyan, his family will never be satisfied, and Sufiyan will always make her back down to cater to his family. It would have been a miserable life and marriage living with toxic people. Sufiyan doesn't have what it takes to make a marriage work, he's too immature and self-centered. He would just blame Ushna for causing unrest in the family, which Ushna would never tolerate.
A reason why Shehroz and Ushna gets so well along and has a good marriage life so far is because of their wonderful in-laws. People that praise them, that encourage them to look into their hearts, that are patient with them, that sorts problems out instead of pointing fingers and taking sides. Ushna looked so relaxed before Raeesa barged in to yell at her, she would never be at peace if she got married to Sufiyan.
I agree with you that Ushna does not love Shehroz yet, she is starting to like and care for him. I think after he got hurt, her feelings for him will gradually grow deeper. Shehroz has a lot of good qualities that she sees, she knows he's trying hard to be a good husband to her, and I think eventually it'll come together to reach her heart.
Also, despite what she felt for Sufiyan in ep 1, it pretty much all died down by the time they lived under the same roof. Ushna can't love someone that stands by to watch her get belittled and have no respect everyday. She only thought about taking his proposal because she didn't want Shehroz, it probably seemed like a lesser of two evils kinda deal. Didn't Ushna tell Zainab that she'd rather marry anyone than Shehroz? Yeah, that was how much she felt for Sufiyan. đ€Ł
Tbh everyone's development has been sidetracked to make way for Sufiyan.
(After reading youtube comments, I finally realized why they showed Sufiyan leaving a plate of daal untouched and walked off, it's to show that he didn't like daal. I can't even. đ)
