Meenakshi and Madhuri - Better dancer? - Page 2

Originally posted by: BettyA1

I heard when MD was new to the field many people said right to her face that she wouldn't make it - one of them was MS

Madhuri has always been about positivity so maybe she just gaslights herself into forgetting the trauma, we love a magnanimous queen.

Originally posted by: BettyA1

I heard when MD was new to the field many people said right to her face that she wouldn't make it - one of them was MS

Meenakshi was called the Ice Queen because she wouldn't talk to anyone in a field where putting yourself out there was the norm. Highly doubt she said anything of the sort to someone's face.

They're great dancers. I find Meenkashi better. Maybe because I like the South Indian dances better, but everyone is entitled to their preference. One thing, though... Meenakshi could never project the same oomph Madhuri did.

Originally posted by: HearMeRoar

Meenakshi was called the Ice Queen because she wouldn't talk to anyone in a field where putting yourself out there was the norm. Highly doubt she said anything of the sort to someone's face.

They're great dancers. I find Meenkashi better. Maybe because I like the South Indian dances better, but everyone is entitled to their preference. One thing, though... Meenakshi could never project the same oomph Madhuri did.

Maybe MS said it behind MD's back and it reached MD's ears somehow... Or maybe she didn't :)

We'll never know the truth...

Bold - Agree, this 21 min clip is one such example which shows MD's range and oomph when it comes to song and dance sequences

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/159361451

Madhuri was more versatile and did folk, western dances too. Effortlessly. Unlike Meenakshi who is technically better than Madhuri in classical dances but somehow lagged behind in western dances and the expressions/body language department.

If it was purely about classical dance then Meenakshi ranks above Madhuri. But if it all forms and genres combined then Madhuri is the queen.

Queen of my heart,

https://youtu.be/gnKkVlvGNrg

https://youtu.be/-R-DMFuKuu8

https://youtu.be/bSYk4e3Edz0

She hold against chiru. That's a huge feat.

Originally posted by: atominis

Madhuri was more versatile and did folk, western dances too. Effortlessly. Unlike Meenakshi who is technically better than Madhuri in classical dances but somehow lagged behind in western dances and the expressions/body language department.

If it was purely about classical dance then Meenakshi ranks above Madhuri. But if it all forms and genres combined then Madhuri is the queen.

Western dance did madhuri know balley or michael jackson type dance?? no but she did basic ones well that doesn't make her great in western dance, Karishma outperformed her in western dance in DTPH. Minakshi clearly wins because she knew 4 different styles of dancing

I do not think Meenakshi could have done Kay Sera sera song as well as Madhuri and matched steps with Prabhudeva as MD did.

I do not recall a single song of Meenakshi where she did western dance well or memorable enough.

Originally posted by: atominis

I do not think Meenakshi could have done Kay Sera sera song as well as Madhuri and matched steps with Prabhudeva as MD did.

I do not recall a single song of Meenakshi where she did western dance well or memorable enough.

That's not matching step with prabhu deva lol, prabhu deva did not even dance just went slow to make madhuri look good, prabhu deva made it so simple that most good female dances could of performed in it.

watch main balawan . you can see meenakshi is much much better than madhuri in ,even western dancing . madhuri is not dancer ,she only can shake her boobs.

Originally posted by: harun98

That's not matching step with prabhu deva lol, prabhu deva did not even dance just went slow to make madhuri look good, prabhu deva made it so simple that most good female dances could of performed in it.