Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

3.1k

Users

14

Likes

101

Frequent Posters

617251 thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#11

I agree that he came across as a hypocrite in many ways. However, despite his own personal failings in the past, yesterday he was simply an older brother who's younger sister was on her death bed as a result of a fight in which her husband essentially called her characterless. So, from that perspective, I think that everything he said was entirely justified and understandable. He was caught up in the heat of his own emotions, because in addition to being his family, Sai is the only one who stood up for him. He has also first-handedly experienced the vileness of the CN vultures, so he was taking out 10 years worth of anger on them. Much of what he said needed to be heard by not just Virat, but also his family members, and for once, the actor resonated with me.

All of this being said, what really bothers me is that if we go by KD, then Pulkit is essentially going to play a part in bringing Virat and Sai back together. So, why say that he is going to take Sai's zimidari and that she will now live with him only to give in once again? In my opinion, the only people who can decide the future of this relationship is Sai and Virat themselves. No one else has any right to make decisions for their relationship. Sai is going to forgive Virat because she is in love herself, and love leaves people vulnerable. She will not be able to live a part from him, just like he won't be able to tolerate the pain of being separated from her. In this matter, not Pulkit nor anyone else should have a say. Yes, he can advise Sai and try to get across his viewpoint, but he is no one to make that decision for her. Anyways, I'm curious to see how this all pans out, because if he is indeed the one to convince Sai to talk to Virat, then all of what he said in the past few episodes would have really been for nothing...

Edited by tptwi - 4 years ago
ppnn7191 thumbnail
5th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#12

I'm so annoyed how the whole track is playing out! the dialogues are so off! Pulkit's acting is awful! And everyone blaming virat for the accident is so silly! yes it led to the situation where sai was emotionally hurt and she ran out of home onto the streets but it wasn't virat who asked her to run onto to the street nor did he push her infront of the car!


I hope the team works towards implementing some logic in the episodes, though its too much to ask for given the pathetic direction, editing and the list goes on!


And I also hope at least someone points out Sai's mistakes also she keeps getting away with almost everything and virat is made to feel terrible when she also has a role to play in the mess they land up in.. Just my opinion!

fatssrilanka thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 4 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: 404_NotFound

@Blue He made fool of himself by saying that . It’s the result of copy paste from KD . KD has suicide so it made sense but here It was an accident and he wasn’t at the accident site nor spoke to Sai but he decided and declared Virat was the culprit and will get him arrested . Another slow clap moment. Can the law abiding citizen get his in laws arrested and then surrender himself .

That's so true. Why can't he arrest his in laws when they have committed worse crimes than Virat? And, Virat cannot be called a culprit. Now, I understand. Just because they have done many favours he chooses to forget the crimes and move on,but Virat hasn't done anything for him so he can't forget and forgive and so he wants to get him punished.

fatssrilanka thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 4 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: MuguetDScorpion


That's true... indirectly threatened to kill Virat. They have the same enemies yet he will gladly return to them if needed... oh yeah for the sake of his wife. 😆

Oh nice... We often discuss in my posts and other posts but never asked your name. 😆

I think he was dreaming that it was a suicide😆

No problem. It happens😆

Akash3Rai thumbnail
4th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#15

A powerful scene of sai where she gave brilliant performance i was not able to connect because of pulkit. He is ok with the chavans that they left his daughter on orphanage , harini could have gone to brothel or any where else if not founded, for him they had done so much to him that it is bigger than even his daughter and wife. And then speaking to virat about agar meri beti hoti dialogue, that was senseless. Yes virat made grave mistakes, but unlike any other characters he accepts this mistake whole heartedly. Here when virat went to his home after ousting track to apologise to pulkit. He could have told the entire truth about the kidnapping and he being the reason sai didn't spoke the truth,but no i got my wife back now no body matters to me. He has no right to decide about the future of a relationship of husband wife without asking consent from anyone of them. More than pakhi he is the villian of sairat , either it's ousting track or manhandling track.

404_NotFound thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 4 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: ppnn7191

I'm so annoyed how the whole track is playing out! the dialogues are so off! Pulkit's acting is awful! And everyone blaming virat for the accident is so silly! yes it led to the situation where sai was emotionally hurt and she ran out of home onto the streets but it wasn't virat who asked her to run onto to the street nor did he push her infront of the car!


I hope the team works towards implementing some logic in the episodes, though its too much to ask for given the pathetic direction, editing and the list goes on!


And I also hope at least someone points out Sai's mistakes also she keeps getting away with almost everything and virat is made to feel terrible when she also has a role to play in the mess they land up in.. Just my opinion!

@Bold this is very much needed in the show . It’s ok to show FL as flawed , their flaws shouldn’t be hidden at the expense of other character. Either show them as flawed or as Mahaan.
404_NotFound thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 4 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: shirasaini

But what I understood is Pulkit just wanted Virat to know what a father would do if his daughter is fighting in the battle for her life just because of his damaad's insecurity/doubt. He sounded more like a father than a JIJU


Consolidating the response for few post having similar views


There is a saying practice before your preach . Pulkit has failed as a father so him mouthing things like he wouldn’t spare anyone who harms his daughter dilutes the message . It’s like a thief saying I would never steal if I was in your position . More than a father figure to Sai he came across self boasting individual forgetting about his shortcomings.


Like I said in my initial post , it’s easy for Pulkit to be unbiased righteous in this situation as he is not really involved and his emotions haven’t overpowered his thinking. If he had behaved rationally when it involved his wife and kid then him saying such dialogues would have some meaning .

ranijain thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 4 years ago
#18

If it was not a matter of life and death, neither Pulkit nor Mohit would behave that way with Virat. They would have consoled him and given him hope. Both Mohit & Pulkit wanted Sai to get back with Virat after he threw her out at midnight.


Pulkit was just out of ICU seeing Sai in that condition and anyone with heart would say this when highly emotional. All he was telling Virat is count your lucky stars the girl is orphan and doesn't have her father alive to question you.


So no one in Chavan family or Pulkit have right to question Virat coz they themselves are flawed?


If tomorrow Virat's daughter goes thru similar issue, should we say Virat should be the last person to question his sil coz he himself did all this in past? He should be the last person to question his father as he himself is abusive to his wife?


If we go by the logic, Virat should quit the Mahila Task force as he should not be handling any domestic violence case as he himself abused his wife twice even if she forgave him eventually.

Edited by ranijain - 4 years ago
404_NotFound thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 4 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: ranijain

If it was not a matter of life and death, neither Pulkit nor Mohit would behave that way with Virat. They would have consoled him and given him hope. Both Mohit & Pulkit sided with Virat and wanted Sai to get back with Virat after he threw her out at midnight.


Pulkit was just out of ICU seeing Sai in that condition and anyone with heart would say this when highly emotional. All he was telling Virat is count your lucky stars the girl is orphan and doesn't have her father alive to question you.


So no one in Chavan family or Pulkit have right to question Virat coz they themselves are flawed?


If tomorrow Virat's daughter goes thru similar issue, should we say Virat should be the last person to question his sil coz he himself did all this in past? He should be the last person to question his father as he himself is abusive to his wife?


If we go by the logic, Virat should quit the Mahila Task force as he should not be handling any domestic violence case as he himself abused his wife twice even if she forgave him eventually.

Like I mentioned earlier , it’s not about Virat here . Yes if Virat mouths dialogues to his son in law similar to what Pulkit did then he will come across as a hypocrite too . Let’s assume for once Virat is a loser , abuser and all that but will that change the fact that Pulkit is a hypocrite and failed his biological under age daughter? When such person says dialogues like he would have killed the man if it was his daughter will raise questions like why didn’t he do that when his daughter was sent to orphanage and why is he falling at the feet of his criminals who abused his daughter and wife
Saichintalli thumbnail
Rocker Thumbnail 5th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: 404_NotFound

Before I write further I would like to set the expectations for this post . The post is not about Virat,Sai or about yesterday’s episode. It about one dialogue that I heard and want to share my views . I intend to stick to that in this post . Following the tradition , do I feel Virat was wrong in recent incidents. Yes he was and he needs anger management classes not for anyone’s sake but for his betterment . I will stop here as this has already been discussed .


Now coming to main topic , when I heard Pulkit saying he would kill if someone hurt his daughter . A immediate reaction was “kill” might have a different meaning in Pulkit’s dictionary. The man who saved those people from getting punished who harmed his daughter and wife is proudly claiming that as a father he would never tolerate anyone hurting his daughter. He literally begged for acceptance for the same people who abused his wife and child for years . He believed his wife who gave birth to their child had happily move on in life and would be married to someone and didn’t even check on her for years . Yes , he waited for her but was it of any use if he believed she had moved on and didn’t bother to check if her parents had caused any harm to her .


I realized it’s very easy to see things as they are, not from a personally biased viewpoint. It’s easy to be neutral, understanding both points of view when it involves others as “emotions” are not involved but the real test is to see if we can be objective when our loved ones are involved . This is where Pulkit failed . I appreciate him for being a family to Sai at such times and repaying her by supporting her at testing time . It was possible for him to be unbiased because he wasn’t emotionally involved with Sai . He failed his wife and daughter a big time .

I am not supporting virat in this issue or bashing pulkit... Yes virat did wrong and someone should point out his mistakes, and I am happy pulkit did but I also agree with you pulkit have no right to use those words who himself left kaku sena even without confronting them for what they did.... He could have said if kj was here the same way mohit said... But ya .. virat should control his anger , for himself .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".