I don’t know if you bother to read the articles you quote from or for that matter even your own posts but the word Palestine has been used for different things by different people since first used by the Greeks to denote a part of Judea. Did you read and understand that: the oldest mention in the historical record was as a part of Judea. The Romans definitely did rename Judea (including parts of Syria) Palestine. If your best claim for Palestine is that Arabs living there began to develop the concept of nationalism in the 1800s, you should know that Mizrahi Jews have lived there continuously for 3000 years and all traditional Jews everywhere have had the concept of nationalism for thousands of years.
I do not dispute the right of Palestinians to have their own state. They will never achieve it by refusing to recognize the reality on the ground today or perverting history to justify that refusal. Israel isn’t going anywhere. They have elite military equipment. They have intelligence agencies they use to spy on friend and foe alike and are expert at playing the world’s great powers. Biden is a Democrat - the American party not in love with Israel - and listen to the way he talks about the current conflict. Palestine doesn’t have the means or allies to defeat Israel. The world cries for them but doesn’t care enough to send their sons to fight and die for them. Palestine can have more generations born, suffer, and die in refugee camps and occupied territories while they plan for Israel’s imminent destruction or they can negotiate freedom in exchange for peace. Palestine can get plenty of ceasefires and status quo’s but there will never be peace and self-rule without the open acceptance of the State of Israel.
Is this what you are saying? There is no evidence for what you are mentioning.
In 135 AD, the Greek "Syria Palaestina" [a] was used in naming a new Roman province from the merger of Roman Syria and Roman Judaea after the Roman authorities crushed the Bar Kokhba Revolt. Circumstantial evidence links Hadrian to the renaming of the province, which took place around the same time as Jerusalem was refounded as Aelia Capitolina, but the precise date of the change in province name is uncertain.[13] The common view that the name change was intended to "sever the connection of the Jews to their historical homeland" is disputed.[14][15]
i never said there is no jew living among them, but you need to tell me, were they minority or majority? How many Mizrahi Jews return to palestine before 1948? And if they did not return to their homeland before that, why didnt they?
Seher Hone Ko Hai
12