Mahabharat Retelecast Discussion Thread 6 - Page 63

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

42.9k

Users

17

Likes

1.1k

Frequent Posters

Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
FlauntPessimism thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

God these Karna fans are so irritating.


I found one on YouTube, he said Karna was Mahan n bla bla, then I said he was involved in Bheem Poisoning. He said no text says that

I gave him the link of KMG Sacred text, he was like we can't be sure this is true kyuki Vyas waali book humaare pass nhi hai, I said BORI has it too, then he said we can't believe everything written in KMG n BORI because there are multiple versions, Geeta Press doesn't say so, I said. Geeta Press does n his answer is that Mukesh Khhanna said that BRC Mahabharata is completely in Geeta Press n since BRC didn't show this, hence Geeta press didn't mention it. And he says Andhe ka Putra andha comment is true just because BRC can't show wrong

I gave him the exact place where it is stated in Geeta Press and he was like we can't ever be sure since no book claims 100% authenticity, these were written around Mauryan era.

Plus his claim Balmahabharat n Mahabharata by RamKrishna mission don't mention Karna doing so(both of them are the summary of the book and not anything real)


I was like if so, then how could we be sure that war happened, maybe Duryodhan had accepted the Shanti Prastav, the writers during Mauryan era changed it.


He then claims Shakuni as very bad, Duryodhan as fool and asked me not to say bad about Karna because we can't be sure that the books we have are true..

FlauntPessimism thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

He is the best Bheem I have encountered. Really awesome

AninditaB thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

God these Karna fans are so irritating.


I found one on YouTube, he said Karna was Mahan n bla bla, then I said he was involved in Bheem Poisoning. He said no text says that

I gave him the link of KMG Sacred text, he was like we can't be sure this is true kyuki Vyas waali book humaare pass nhi hai, I said BORI has it too, then he said we can't believe everything written in KMG n BORI because there are multiple versions, Geeta Press doesn't say so, I said. Geeta Press does n his answer is that Mukesh Khhanna said that BRC Mahabharata is completely in Geeta Press n since BRC didn't show this, hence Geeta press didn't mention it. And he says Andhe ka Putra andha comment is true just because BRC can't show wrong

I gave him the exact place where it is stated in Geeta Press and he was like we can't ever be sure since no book claims 100% authenticity, these were written around Mauryan era.

Plus his claim Balmahabharat n Mahabharata by RamKrishna mission don't mention Karna doing so(both of them are the summary of the book and not anything real)


I was like if so, then how could we be sure that war happened, maybe Duryodhan had accepted the Shanti Prastav, the writers during Mauryan era changed it.


He then claims Shakuni as very bad, Duryodhan as fool and asked me not to say bad about Karna because we can't be sure that the books we have are true..


Karna fans are highly delusional ones

FlauntPessimism thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: Andy3456


Karna fans are highly delusional ones

Yaar according to him Karna would have definitely stopped Duryodhan for the war, but since Duryodhan was stupid he accepted what Shakuni said and went for war


So it's like we can't be sure of what's written but we can be sure of what's not written

AninditaB thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Yaar according to him Karna would have definitely stopped Duryodhan for the war, but since Duryodhan was stupid he accepted what Shakuni said and went for war


So it's like we can't be sure of what's written but we can be sure of what's not written

😆😆

Mages thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

God these Karna fans are so irritating.


I found one on YouTube, he said Karna was Mahan n bla bla, then I said he was involved in Bheem Poisoning. He said no text says that

I gave him the link of KMG Sacred text, he was like we can't be sure this is true kyuki Vyas waali book humaare pass nhi hai, I said BORI has it too, then he said we can't believe everything written in KMG n BORI because there are multiple versions, Geeta Press doesn't say so, I said. Geeta Press does n his answer is that Mukesh Khhanna said that BRC Mahabharata is completely in Geeta Press n since BRC didn't show this, hence Geeta press didn't mention it. And he says Andhe ka Putra andha comment is true just because BRC can't show wrong

I gave him the exact place where it is stated in Geeta Press and he was like we can't ever be sure since no book claims 100% authenticity, these were written around Mauryan era.

Plus his claim Balmahabharat n Mahabharata by RamKrishna mission don't mention Karna doing so(both of them are the summary of the book and not anything real)


I was like if so, then how could we be sure that war happened, maybe Duryodhan had accepted the Shanti Prastav, the writers during Mauryan era changed it.


He then claims Shakuni as very bad, Duryodhan as fool and asked me not to say bad about Karna because we can't be sure that the books we have are true..


karna fans are stupid delusional idiots🤮🤮

these are the few idiots who believes the karna-draupadi love story shitfest🤮😡they can go any extend to prove karna was a noble being and arjun was a monster and he doesn't deserve draupadi🤮🤮of all pandavas this group hates arjun to the core🤮


I had one debate with karna fans gosh they spoke so ill abt arjun that group is from YT

Edited by Mages - 5 years ago
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

I saw Pooja for the first time in Mahakali. I had seen SRJ as Vishnu in Devo ke dev and God I fell so much in love with PooRabh...☺️

https://twitter.com/PoojaFan_/status/1284025906768408576?s=19

This wedding is absolute fave. ❤️

Really loved them both in MB and I hope they will work together again sometime.

Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

Amazing Drau edit on Padmavat's Rani sa..

https://youtu.be/vKEl_8toLn4

Agni_Jytsona thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

God these Karna fans are so irritating.


I found one on YouTube, he said Karna was Mahan n bla bla, then I said he was involved in Bheem Poisoning. He said no text says that

I gave him the link of KMG Sacred text, he was like we can't be sure this is true kyuki Vyas waali book humaare pass nhi hai, I said BORI has it too, then he said we can't believe everything written in KMG n BORI because there are multiple versions, Geeta Press doesn't say so, I said. Geeta Press does n his answer is that Mukesh Khhanna said that BRC Mahabharata is completely in Geeta Press n since BRC didn't show this, hence Geeta press didn't mention it. And he says Andhe ka Putra andha comment is true just because BRC can't show wrong

I gave him the exact place where it is stated in Geeta Press and he was like we can't ever be sure since no book claims 100% authenticity, these were written around Mauryan era.

Plus his claim Balmahabharat n Mahabharata by RamKrishna mission don't mention Karna doing so(both of them are the summary of the book and not anything real)


I was like if so, then how could we be sure that war happened, maybe Duryodhan had accepted the Shanti Prastav, the writers during Mauryan era changed it.


He then claims Shakuni as very bad, Duryodhan as fool and asked me not to say bad about Karna because we can't be sure that the books we have are true..

Among all Mahabharata fans karna fans ars the most delusional of the lot. You can never talk sense with some of them. Followed by yudhishtra fans.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".