Looking for Alaska
I am a book purist. Every time I watch something based on a book I've read, I'm left with a sense of dissatisfaction. I love Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, and Hunger Games movies. But the books are so much more. The Fault in Our Stars movie paled in comparison to John Green's original book. The saccharine soaked romance overpowered the sarcasm and irreverence the teen protagonists had.
Looking for Alaska changes a lot from the book (John Green's first novel). Instead of a movie, Hulu stretches it out to a mini-series. They take a lot of liberties with events that happen in the book. Despite all the tinkering, Looking for Alaska greatly improves upon the book. I never thought this was possible.
John Green writes nerd fiction inspired by his own life experiences. Although the book is wonderfully written, the protagonist Miles Halter suffers from a bit of myopia. Chip is irrationally angry. Alaska is frustratingly fickle. The staff like Starnes and Hyde tend to be one dimensional. The show gets out of Miles' head and lets us see the characters from an outside perspective.
As a gifted but poor and black student, Chip's anger at institutional racism and the callousness of the privileged makes sense. A tragic childhood loss and broken family have shaped Alaska. Yes, she is a vivacious and smart young woman who loves pranks and battling the patriarchy. But she is also someone battling extreme depression and alcoholism. Her mood swings make sense and she doesn't seem fickle anymore. We get opportunities to see Starnes and Hyde beyond the classroom to see them as humans who have their own ups and downs in life.
Set in the early 2000's Alabama, Looking for Alaska is a wonderful work of teenage drama. But unlike some other shows of the genre, it remains incredibly grounded in reality. In some ways 'Looking for Alaska' and '13 reasons why' are two sides of the same coin.
'13 reasons why' is about holding on and answering questions. 'Looking for Alaska' is about letting go and embracing life's unanswerable mysteries. Which is why 13 reasons why goes on and on, because there are always more questions to answer. But Looking for Alaska ends with a life-affirming, joyous, and totally insane celebration of subverting the patriarchy.
716