Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

10.3k

Users

10

Likes

43

Frequent Posters

InaMeenaDika thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

I dont think they can come up with an excuse besides she was in a coma for 3 years....woke up to go to kartik saw him with vedika realized he thought she died and fluttered off ...

that isnt going to happen because, her friend mentioned she never told her story for 5 years...

also how can she never look back???


there is some secret that the singhanias dont keep contact with the goenkas may be they know naira is alive and even that isnt justified its all a sick story line

like the mental torture kartik goes threw to love naira is sick....i thought they would show me for once in his life he moved on to something other than fixating everything on one person...now that person being vansh....

imagine when kairav enters how obsessed he will be +_+ hel quit his job to spend time with the kid like dev did in kuch rang

But she said that baby aur mumma dono papa kr paas laut jayenge, means she did intend to go back to Kartik. Something should have happened that would have changed her decision. Of course whatever it is, it has to be illogical and weird😆

May be she came back during her chautha ceremony and thought that Kartik got so mad at her for cheating with Mihir that he declared her dead, so she went away.. 🤣TV charaters can think anything.😆

CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

I dont think they can come up with an excuse besides she was in a coma for 3 years....woke up to go to kartik saw him with vedika realized he thought she died and fluttered off ...

that isnt going to happen because, her friend mentioned she never told her story for 5 years...

also how can she never look back???


there is some secret that the singhanias dont keep contact with the goenkas may be they know naira is alive and even that isnt justified its all a sick story line

like the mental torture kartik goes threw to love naira is sick....i thought they would show me for once in his life he moved on to something other than fixating everything on one person...now that person being vansh....

imagine when kairav enters how obsessed he will be +_+ hel quit his job to spend time with the kid like dev did in kuch rang

@bold you read my mind his is exactly what I thought!...the only way her keeping Kairav away from Kartik can be redeemed not justified though is...she was in coma for 3 years...returned and saw Kartik happy with Vedika...but this is not going to happen...as yes her friend mentioned she never returned back....why would her actions be justified by something like this?....for this writers need to waste few minutes in backstory...they will instead prefer introducing a dream sequence...she won't have any back story other than I left Kartik for my self respect blah blah...I kept Kairav away from Kartik because I became selfish in keeping him for myself...I had reason for existence but deprived Kartik of his reason for existence...If this happens that I will quit watching yrkkh...

Naira wasn't given a proper breakdown scene after her child's death...had breakdown after ages...would her actions be justified? I don't think so...If writers are wise they will try to justify actions of Naira too the way they showed what Kartik went through before asking that question...they tried to mellow down Kartik during separation phase to justify both of their actions...same goes for clot track...but than they lost all senses while launching their new show...

@red that's true...Naira, Keerti, Shubham, Suwarna, Naira...

TeenRose1 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#13

Yes, she shud rather be direct and gave him a slap and a class. Feeling sorry for Kairav. He seems sad and longing for his father.

Shivangi is portraying matured woman brilliantly. Surprised she agreed to the 5 yr leap and playing mother.

Edited by TeenRose1 - 6 years ago
TeenRose1 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: ZindagiCalling

But she said that baby aur mumma dono papa kr paas laut jayenge, means she did intend to go back to Kartik. Something should have happened that would have changed her decision. Of course whatever it is, it has to be illogical and weird😆

May be she came back during her chautha ceremony and thought that Kartik got so mad at her for cheating with Mihir that he declared her dead, so she went away.. 🤣TV charaters can think anything.😆

LOL! 🤣

TeenRose1 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

As for kaira our baby (i was like awww they have kid now, and i died)

I was expecting him to be annoying but i kind of hope they make him a minnie kartik

i think it would be so cute to watch

they should have made him say krishna ji

and been like when his moms angry shes like a sherni and she rawrs...

He does have mom's looks and dad's personality

Fari_15 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#16

I feel sorry for Naira tbh because of the plot line being given to her just to show this forced separation.

She's coming across as a selfish person with a huge ego. The only person she seems to be thinking about in this situation is herself, not her son, not Kartik, not her family. Its all about I, me, myself for her right now. Her anger, her self-respect.

Self-respect doesn't mean you walk away from the situation. That's being a coward not an independent woman who doesn't need any man's protection or support.

Even if she hates Kartik, that doesn't give her the right to separate a child from his father, his family.

How is she not realizing the pain she is putting her son through, who can't even ask about his father's whereabouts because he fears it would upset his mother.

Naira hiding Kartik's tattoo with a lotus isn't symbolic in my opinion. To me it seems she would go to any extent to hide Kartik and his existence from THEIR son.

Kartik needs to file a custody case after he finds out about his son, but I bet he would be the bad person yet again.

rose2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#17

They sabotaged Karthik's character in the last few tracks so to balance it out now they have done the same with Naira. Both have been shown as immature and impulsive. Both don't learn from their mistakes. The sad fact is five years have passed but both are still stuck in time and have not been able to really move forward. I preferred Naira as the successful jewelry designer vs what she has become now. Even Karthik is rude to that other girl that lives in the Goenka home. He is and will always be angry young man.


Not impressed at all after leap. One thing I don't understand why Naira's son looks older than Gayu's son? Wasn't Gayu pregnant before Naira? Remind me again. Trying to find any logic is useless.


Show has become a total bore.












CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: rose2015

They sabotaged Karthik's character in the last few tracks so to balance it out now they have done the same with Naira. Both have been shown as immature and impulsive. Both don't learn from their mistakes. The sad fact is five years have passed but both are still stuck in time and have not been able to really move forward. I preferred Naira as the successful jewelry designer vs what she has become now. Even Karthik is rude to that other girl that lives in the Goenka home. He is and will always be angry young man.


Not impressed at all after leap. One thing I don't understand why Naira's son looks older than Gayu's son? Wasn't Gayu pregnant before Naira? Remind me again. Trying to find any logic is useless.


Show has become a total bore.

@bold Kartik received same amount of "love" during baby swap track specifically in IF...

Ajscinesonadar thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#19

Kairav baby will go back to papa along with his mumma is endgame. Whereas kaira first baby girl even a glimpse of baby naira didn't see.

Irony is Kartik was loved and cheered for his act including me, but naira getting hatred even without knowing real reason of hiding from kartik not just from kartik even from her own family and she is punishing herself as well. But only Kartik's pain currently visible to some of the people when naira also equally hurt yea she was oblivious to his feeling so she deserves it.

Ps : Kartik is cute so even if he do anything its okay. 😛

Makers better have proper explanation for naira being away from her family. When she actually wanted to go back to him before the leap. I strongly believe it's wrong of naira for hiding a small kid from his father the reason I'm expwcting a strong reason for the same.

Or if this stupid act of her is just to make kartik justify and make him mahaan. I say the writers being writers "koi bhi kuch bhi kare" be it kartik, Kdadi, swarna whoever, in the end naira has to say sorry, except naira no one can be wrong with patent dialogue "Tumari wajaseh sab kuch hota hai" 😆

Edited by Ajscinesonadar - 6 years ago
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Ajscinesonadar

Kairav baby will go back to papa along with his mumma is endgame. Whereas kaira first baby girl even a glimpse of baby naira didn't see.

Irony is Kartik was loved and cheered for his act including me, but naira getting hatred even without knowing real reason of hiding from kartik not just from kartik even from her own family and she is punishing herself as well. But only Kartik's pain currently visible to some of the people when naira also equally hurt yea she was oblivious to his feeling so she deserves it.

Ps : Kartik is cute so even if he do anything its okay. 😛

Makers better have proper explanation for naira being away from her family. When she actually wanted to go back to him before the leap. I strongly believe it's wrong of naira for hiding a small kid from his father the reason I'm expwcting a strong reason for the same.

Or if this stupid act of her is just to make kartik justify and make him mahaan. I say the writers being writers "koi bhi kuch bhi kare" be it kartik, Kdadi, swarna whoever, in the end naira has to say sorry, except naira no one can be wrong with patent dialogue "Tumari wajaseh sab kuch hota hai" 😆


I feel with kartik i have always said it straight when he was wrong why does naira deserve some extra special treatment. No reason what so ever will be good enough for her separating kairav from kartik. And not talking to her own family what did they do to her?

Why is she raising kairav in poverty and not giving him the life he deserves all because of her ego. Being strong doesnt mean you should run away from your problems...

Also kartik keeping the dead baby away from naira back then was wrong. But he had his reasons naira had health issues and kept saying she would die if so and so happened etc...also when he was blamed for it he stood up and faced the criticism boldly he didnt run away to goa for 10 years and not contact anyone like honestly who does that...

sure the makers can cough up some reason three hundred seconds later naira saw him with vedika bla bla...but still it hurts her not kairav. kairav deserves to know his family. Grow up knowing his family.

How can one question Kartik asked in his weakest moment suddenly give him such a big punishment... that he lives thinking shes dead and not knowing his son exists... There was so much build up to kartik going against his character by asking naira what he did....but no build up at all with what naira did so she seems dumb for now...is what i am saying...maybe more cards will explain it but i just dont think that any reason can justify it...Just like when kartik threw naira out for Ma ka dard...nothing could justify him...

her baby doesnt even know her real name....

that poor kid +_+ and poor Kartik who lives thinking she died because of him all because she couldnt face him and tell him off to his face...

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: BangBang_Shilpa · 2 months ago

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DTdstvekued/?igsh=MTgxMjhqa2cxMjBlNA==

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DTdstvekued/
Expand â–¼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Avalayarima · 1 months ago

I have been watching this show for 5 years now and followed this forum. Every generation’s female lead, from original Akshira to Abeera, has...

Expand â–¼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Ajab.Pehchan · 1 months ago

I don’t recall any other PH humiliating their FL to this extent.

Expand â–¼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01 · 2 months ago

I’m happy they are still there. Reminds me of Akshara and Naira old vibes. Arman and his daughter

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".