Overreaction Much.... - Page 4

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Yeah it's pretty hilarious irony that Shivaay literally hasn't said or done anything yet in this track to give Anika cause to pick on him...he's managed to handle his internal conflict surprisingly well so far and yes indeed has come a long way from the days when he had to act out and say crap about Anika simply to dismiss the possibility of having any feelings for her😆

Surprisingly, I can't find any fault in his actions. He's being unexpectedly calm and mature through all this. Which is also so strange. Itna buildup about NKK for 200 odd episodes and now this! Not that I'm not happy with his stance, but a little more explanation would have been nice.😃

So then it's kinda extra sad that Anika has to be butchered in the process while Shivaay's character evolves...Harneet's obsession with focusing only on Shivaay's characterization unfortunately leaves only Anika to use for senseless drama without rhyme or reason.

I completely agree! I never saw the point of Mahi's character anyway. I mean NM does a pretty good job of portraying the flip between the two characters but seriously what's the point?! Use that time to show us what Annika is thinking about her present situation (apart from the random dreamy eyes and 2-minute half baked conversations with Sahil) or just show Rumya if nothing else. Annika really needs some character development right now. I really hope this past revelation is only about Annika and doesn't twist back to Mahi story.

LOLL Anika's work is an even bigger afterthought for the writers than Anika's past...I would be very surprised if this track ended up revealing anything about her past...they'll find a way to twist back to Mahi's sob-story somehow again and keep the focus on the Shivaay-Mahi issue...lol

Yes, a working Anika track would have been a believable track in terms of their ideological ego clashes...instead we are being given an Anika who just desperately wants to hear "Tum meri biwi ho" from Shivaay day and night...😆...no other thought exists in her head anymore.

Originally posted by: _SilverLining_

It can only go one of the two ways - either he accepts her or not. And though his NKK will not disappear in a day it seems like he is trying to accept her as she is. So why the huge interest in her past? What will change if he comes to know who she was?

For eg if he finds out she was the daughter of a paanwala will he be able to leave her after all that they've experienced together?

And if she's the daughter of a renowned businessman will he be able to live freely with her till the ends of time, despite knowing that he went behind her back even after all the things that she told him today and even the thought of that is disturbing to me. Where is he leading with all this?

Aisa lagg raha hai they're doing this just so they can lead to the track about unraveling Annika's past, and the so called 'truth'.

@silverlining sorry don't know your name my dear but I guess the intrest is caz he needs to know something to tell his children bache bhi toh poocheinge na maa kiska khoon hai *rollseyes* which again is bizzare for me caz really kisi bhi bache ko is baat se kya farak padta hai ke uske maa baap ke NKK kya hai as far as they have the love of their parents. I haven't heard or encountered a single child who went upto their parents and asked bhai aap kiska khoon ho or aapke khoon ki speciality kya hai?

Originally posted by: naadanmasakalli

@silverlining sorry don't know your name my dear but I guess the intrest is caz he needs to know something to tell his children bache bhi toh poocheinge na maa kiska khoon hai *rollseyes* which again is bizzare for me caz really kisi bhi bache ko is baat se kya farak padta hai ke uske maa baap ke NKK kya hai as far as they have the love of their parents. I haven't heard or encountered a single child who went upto their parents and asked bhai aap kiska khoon ho or aapke khoon ki speciality kya hai?

The last scene was clearly a TRP milking ruse. Bechari heroine ki sad story types:P

Originally posted by: naadanmasakalli

@silverlining sorry don't know your name my dear but I guess the intrest is caz he needs to know something to tell his children bache bhi toh poocheinge na maa kiska khoon hai *rollseyes* which again is bizzare for me caz really kisi bhi bache ko is baat se kya farak padta hai ke uske maa baap ke NKK kya hai as far as they have the love of their parents. I haven't heard or encountered a single child who went upto their parents and asked bhai aap kiska khoon ho or aapke khoon ki speciality kya hai?

Fary... I dont completely agree with u... Agreed annika has an over reaction... She always knew NKK matters at lot to him so when she expected he wud end their relationship when he comes to know she is an orphan why such an over reaction when he just told her she will always be his wife n that won't change... But Her getting angry on him is valid... If He dint hv anything to hide and was genuinely wanting to dig her past to shut ppl up.. He wud hv spoken to her after calming her and saying u know me I hv always believed in NKK... U r my wife n that won't change ever... U mean a lot more to me but I still want to find out bout ur past... Instead He chose to confide in his brothers that they know how he thinks about this n his views r different from them and they don't agree with his thot... Annika is at no fault but he needs to know his wife's bg... N All this when he just told her she will remain his wife... If she will then y does he need to know her past? Will her past change his views about her? Her walking out wasn't justified but her anger was... After telling someone u will b my wife n I will make things fine... U yo about telling ur brother u need to know her bg... Her asking if what they share between them wasn't big enuf for him to accept her as just Annika too is right... She nvr expected him to accept her... So if he did either he shud hv done it whole heartedly or shud hv told her that he needed time to totally accept it though she is more imp to him... See He actually thinks of her as wife but not the mom of his kids yet... He Exactly thinks what pinky asked him... Else He wud hv told pinky how does Annika's bg mean anything to his kids... It's upto elders not to speak about it n even if they do he is proud of what she is... But he dint say that... He kept quiet...

And i do understand Shivaay's urge to dig into Anika's past.

Originally posted by: YeHoKyaRahaHai

And i do understand Shivaay's urge to dig into Anika's past.

Actually adopted children themselves are quite curious to know their biological parents because it contributes to their sense of identity, a sense of belonging and also myriad things like medical history..etc,

I'm actually surprised as to why Anika herself hasn't tried to do that. She has a younger sister too so why isn't she delving deeper into this?

Originally posted by: YeHoKyaRahaHai

And i do understand Shivaay's urge to dig into Anika's past.

Actually adopted children themselves are quite curious to know their biological parents because it contributes to their sense of identity, a sense of belonging and also myriad things like medical history..etc,

I'm actually surprised as to why Anika herself hasn't tried to do that. She has a younger sister too so why isn't she delving deeper into this?

Exactly Amri - the issue is harneet is not invested in Anika or building Her up. All her love is going towards mahi who is not even needed in the story but that's just my opinion

Every adopted kid I have known wants to know their past just to know and not to leave their parents or family
Who have brought them up. Case in point - one of the best movies I have seen recently - lion and it's based on true story. Also sushmita said She will tell the girls their real parents identities when they are 18 and able to make sense of it - clearly she is not scared of losing them or anything, it is just the right thing to do

So Anika howling at end was over done for me. She could have shed silent tears or spoken in a heavy voice which would have made it sound like she was holding her tears back and the scene would have been so much More poignant