could anyone else have played Neerja - Page 2

Originally posted by: Live2eat

Aditi Rao hydari

Amruta puri

Originally posted by: ViccoTurmeric

Neerja's brother had said that they would have had believed Sonam to be reincarnation of Neerja if she was born an year later or so

She has an uncanny resemblance to her and so is her voice! Like WOW!

Also she gave full justice to Neerja and played her part with full honesty and dedication! Really gratifying to see her emerge as such a strong performer in film.. Blew me over

Having said that had the film been fictionalized or was not based on a real story then any leading actress could have been better than her!

Originally posted by: ibelieveinpink

No.

Sonam looks so much like Neerja and has the right personality to play her.

Kangana was meant for Tanu, Deepika for Piku, PC for Jhilmil, etc. And Sonam was born for this role.

Originally posted by: Divine-Pearl

Could anyone else have played Nirja ?

Could anyone else have played Veronica ?

Could anyone else have played dutto ?

Could anyone else have played Marry kom?

Could anyone else have played Vidya from kahani?

All are irrelevant questions, we can never know the answer. Anyone else never got a chance to play that character having said that, role belongs to the one who has played it. We actually don't want to imagine anyone else after watching a movie which was perfect or beyond perfect.

Originally posted by: ViccoTurmeric

Also about terrorist thing.. No one was laughing on his accent atleast here

SPOILER

There was a moment when he looses his patience and experiences a panic attack - cut to he is sitting on chair like zoombie! That was painfully hilarious!

Also when he starts to snap his fingers (Neerja was singing)

Originally posted by: helloitsme28

WOW ...

I thought this was a forum where you could have discussions ! I wasn't try to put anyone down or dissing anyone, I applauded Sonam for her work as well.

I just wanted to know how everyone felt about the convo I overheard.

maybe it was perfect to you ... for others it could have been better had there been another actress ( and in no way is someone being disrespectful to Neerja by wishing for another actress ) everyone is entitled to their opinion.

but thanks for your sharing how you felt anyways hehe

Originally posted by: helloitsme28

Wow really ! even her voice ... that's super crazy ! I agree i am so proud of Sonam for pulling it off !

hmm interesting ... thanks for your opinion !