Do We Women Need Pity from Judges to Win

CONTEST : IPL 2026 Prediction Game

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

ticks

@ticks

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#31

Amit is my Indian Idol too and I dont mind Emon.

I really hope JA's words galvinizes Emon's base to takehim to Top 2.

And Amit Fans unite to vote for Amit to get him to Top 2.

Finally, Girls dont need quota and sympathy. If a Girl is talented she will rise. We dont need JA's bhashan. Kiran Bedi or Indra Noori or Lata Mangeskar or countless others did not need JA's lecture. Ankita was not a good singer, just performance is not enough!

Edited by ticks - 18 years ago

Quote

syrene

@syrene

Voyager

Posted: 18 years ago

#32

Originally posted by: Rajat-sh

Shreya, deepali, Smita all were good. Per it is you girls who dont vote for them. Tum sab boys ke liye vote bhej the ho. Then how will girls get a chance?

Wether you realize it or not, Ankita inspired millions of small town girls to be free spirits. That is what JA was encouraging. You narrow minded attitude is doing a disservice to girls.

Maybe you will never get it.

Well said 👏

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Manju

@Modesty

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#33

Originally posted by: Maya_M
I thought this is a singing talent show. If this was about woman's upliftment then they should have specified that and awarded it to the last woman left. Tonight Javed ji's speech looked like he was advocating for 33% reservation for woman in parliament.

Javed ji, Wrong platform. This is Indian Idol not Indian parliament.

Well said, Maya. 😆😆😆 Javedji ka dimaag shaayad thoda kharaab ho gaya hai. I know I am being rude here. I can't help it.

I am not dismissive of his judging capabilites for the other day I saw Shankar Mahadevan's interview on TV where he was praising Javedji's genius as far as classical music is concerned. How he sits with the doyens of Indian classical music and discusses nuances of the same with them.

But his incessant support to Ankita is beyond my comprehension.

Thanks.

Quote

Rajat-sh

@Rajat-sh

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#34

your comprehension is very limited obviously.

Quote

Manju

@Modesty

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: Rajat-sh
your comprehension is very limited obviously.

I am entitled to my opinion as you are entitled to yours. What if I say the same about you?

TC.

Quote

syrene

@syrene

Voyager

Posted: 18 years ago

#36

Men these days are totally in a fix....Don't support women and u will be called an MCP and support them and be called condescending or biwi ka ghulam 😆

Quote

193980

Suspended

Posted: 18 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: Modesty

Well said, Maya. 😆😆😆 Javedji ka dimaag shaayad thoda kharaab ho gaya hai. I know I am being rude here. I can't help it.

I am not dismissive of his judging capabilites for the other day I saw Shankar Mahadevan's interview on TV where he was praising Javedji's genius as far as classical music is concerned. How he sits with the doyens of Indian classical music and discusses nuances of the same with them.

But his incessant support to Ankita is beyond my comprehension.

Thanks.

Galtiyaan to sabse hoti hain phir Javed ji kya different hain😉😆. He just brought home to work.😆

Quote

193980

Suspended

Posted: 18 years ago

#38

And we blame Alisha for supporting her Chingu-Mingu and getting hyper for Suhit. 😛

Quote

sumanforums

@sumanforums

Navigator

Posted: 18 years ago

#39

Girls dont need pity or support...they can do it on their own....If the Indian Idol guys wanted a girl why did they want the boys to partcipate at all. I believe they should have just told the boys please go home come another season. This season we want only A GIRL.

Reality shows are just about talent + humbleness which contects to the audience.....A girl or boy does not matter. I am a girl and i vote for Amit Paul...but had Smita or jolly been there i would be voting for them as they are good singers and good human beings as well. I like Ankita but i do not vote for her becasue i do not like her singing. It is talent that matters and not the gender.

Quote

anjalibc

@anjalibc

Voyager

Posted: 18 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: sumanforums
Girls dont need pity or support...they can do it on their own....If the Indian Idol guys wanted a girl why did they want the boys to partcipate at all. I believe they should have just told the boys please go home come another season. This season we want only A GIRL.

Reality shows are just about talent + humbleness which contects to the audience.....A girl or boy does not matter. I am a girl and i vote for Amit Paul...but had Smita or jolly been there i would be voting for them as they are good singers and good human beings as well. I like Ankita but i do not vote for her becasue i do not like her singing. It is talent that matters and not the gender.

Absolutely right. I was voting in fact for Deepali, Pooja Chang, Amit Emon to bring them upto top level and the besura's get eliminated. But sadly...