Originally posted by: khamosshhh
From the onset let me say tht my POV will be different from others based on my sensibilities and dat does not make me right or the other person wrong. Coming to Ranbir Kapoor, I find him a good actor not a great one, so I am not surprised tht he did not perform well in a weak scripted or badly made movie.😳
Guess I am hard to please and till now for me the only actor who I found gr8 across all generations and gender is Madhuri. She is such a restrained actor and does her roles with so much of subtlety and naturalness that u just see the character she is doing and tht character leaves an impression or u take notice of tht character even when it's a weak movie and character. Maybe memorable isn't d right word, but makes a person notice a character or the character makes his/ her presence felt even if it's not author backed. And dat's how I felt abt Madhuri. Unfortunately such nuanced performances tend to get overlooked and the more OTT or flamboyant performances get noticed and appreciated too.😕
I never thought I wld come across any other actor like dat, but as luck would have it I did and it was Fawad Khan and Sanam Saeed . A few years back some of my relative asked me to watch dis Pak drama Humsafar nd dey kept gushing over it. So I decided to gv it a try and even after watching a few episodes, I didn't quite get what the hype was all about. Though at that time I didn't even have any clue abt just how famous Humsafar was! But what did catch my attention was d male lead and I was just amazed at d screen presence he commanded and the way he was emoting nd den itself I had decided that I wld watch dis one for him. But never got abt to watching it and only after Zindagi aired it did I watch it.
In d meantime I watched ZGH nd dat too not the first time it was aired on Zindagi, but afterwards coz someone kept recommending me to watch it, so I watched it on YT. Was totally clueless abt dis show and didn't even know dat it was the same Humsafar guy who was in dis show too. Was already impressed by him but den watched Sanam in ZGH and was totally bowled over by her performance too And as I always said yes she edged out Fawad where performance was concerned coz her Kashaf was such a fantastically etched out character by Umera. Now have watched almost all d shows of Sanam and she has left me impressed with her every performance. I never see Sanam in her characters, so well does she get into the skin of the character. And I have even watched Daam, and according to me she did a fantastic job in Daam too, though she hardly had much screen space, even lesser than Zara's siblings, mamu, parents and others and yet she made her presence felt and I thought I wld never hate Fiza coz it was Sanam who was portraying her, but I too got irritated with her character's selfishness and total disregard for others and wanted her out of Junaid's life. So credit to her for making her character so unlikable. Her only drawback was tht I found her rushing through her dialogues, but it didn't take anything away from her acting as such.
So for me an actor who catches my attention by their restrained and subtle performance and yet have the screen presence even when dey r not doing anything in a scene and their body language and persona reeks of the character they r performing, edges out on good actors and there are of course many good actors. BTW d same happened when I was watching this Nandita Das movie Firaaq. One of the actors so caught my attention and I found him really brilliant and much later when he has done a couple of good movies where he finally got recognition did I come to know his name and that is Nawazuddin Siddiqui and though I haven't seen a lot of his work, but he does grab my attention in which ever movie he is in.