StarPaanchaali's Pratiyogita-Pg 147 Samraat Yudhishtir nears 200+ - Page 96

Originally posted by: RonMione4ever

Woah !! Too much negative marking for my Bheema .. One -2 is sufficient, rest should have been -0.5 .. Also he should get positive marks for his gada fight, throwing pitamaha on ground, cutting him with sword .. Why so much harshness against Bheema ??

Originally posted by: Sabhayata

Since this was the final battle for killing pitamah any hesitation shown to kill him will be marked as per option A of war scoring scheme

for combined hesitation marks will be shared by all pratiyogi's for individual hesitation pratoyogi's will get individual marking

please feel free to raise objections

Scoring 29th jun 2014	y	b	a	n	s
1)Bheeshm asks pandavs to kill him for the first time,panadavs hesitate	-.40	-.40	-.40	-.40	-.40
2)Bheeshm exclusively addresses bhima to fight with him but bhima doesnt		-2
3)Bheeshm asks pandavs to fight with him for the second time .Bhima hesiatate and says they cant.Yudi and arjuna also hesitate.Nakula nd sahdev not shown	-1	-2	-1
4)Bheeshm asks nakul and sahdev to come and fight with him and sahdev refuses					-2.
5)3rd time bheehsma asks pandvas to attack him they again don't	-0.4	-0.4	-0.4	-0.4	-0.4
6)Bheeshma asks arjuna to come and fight with him arjuna hesitates			-2.
7)4th time bheeshma asks pandavs to attack him but pandavs don't	-0.4	-0.4	-0.4	-0.4	-0.4
8)panadavs finally attack bheeshma	0.50	0.50	0.50	0.50	0.50
9)bheeshma then for the 5th time asks pandvas to attack him with the mace they don't	-0.4	-0.4	-0.4	-0.4	-0.4
10)Yudi and arjuna fight with bheeshma	0.50		0.50
11)Nakula and sahdev fight with bheeshma				0.50	0.50
12)Pitamah then again asks bheem to attack him but bheem doesn't		-2.
13)Bheem finally attacks pitamah		0.50
14)pandvas fight with pitamah with a sword	0.50	0.50	0.50	0.50	0.50
Total	-1.1	-6.1	-3.1	-0.1	-2.1

Originally posted by: -bharti

Can I raise some objections? Am a newbie so may be I am not right in objecting...

But still I would do...I just cannot stop myself after resisting for so many months...😆

@Red: Please be a little less harsh on Bheema and do not cut this 2 marks, or at least deduct only 1 marks. You have already deducted another 2 marks for the same reason in the next row.

Also you have given points to YANS for fighting with mace to Bheeshma, but haven't awarded Bheema any points for his solo-fight with Pitamah. He should get 1 marks for fight and 1 marks for throwing off Bheeshma to the ground.

Also during the sword fight, B and A both succeeded in injuring Pitamah's arms, please award them 1 point each for that!

Originally posted by: AnjanaYYZ

Can we please give StarPandav NEGATIVE MARKS for their PATHETIC EFFORTS AGAINST Bhisma today?😈

Originally posted by: --Yukthi--

All the pati's have been deducted with the same points...If we check the table.

It's just that when Bhishma asked bhima to fight him...bhima did not.

Hence he scored an extra -2. 😊

Bhima is the most emotional one , who loves his family. he is very expressive...hence he gains and looses points very easily...as the situation demands.

the deductions are the same otherwise

And yes I do agree , Arjun and bhima were the ONLY two who were successful in injuring pitamah.

so they should get extra points. 😊

Originally posted by: thearcher

Wont they also lose points for being wimpy fighters?

@Saanthiya, she was standing btw Yudhi and Arjun. If fav arya gets points so will jyesht