Shrimad Ramayan Episode Discussion Thread : 26-09-2024 - Page 7

Originally posted by: Niharika_17

Ya authenticity wise rs ramayan and ndtv ramayan are good but ya rs ramayan is according to rcm mainly and in ndtv they followed incidents of vr too

But I can't connect with rs ramayan Arun govil looks too old for me as Shri Ram maybe generation thing so now sujay is imprinted in my heart as Shri Ram but if I liked someone before sujay as Shri Ram so he is gurmeet Chaudhry

Generation gap u r right. We saw all three

Arun govil is still seen as original ram

Recently u must hv seen during ram lalla pran pratishthan

Gurmeet was good and now sujay

All three hv really got it right

In between others came but couldn't match up

Originally posted by: chatterbox

Generation gap u r right. We saw all three

Arun govil is still seen as original ram

Recently u must hv seen during ram lalla pran pratishthan

Gurmeet was good and now sujay

All three hv really got it right

In between others came but couldn't match up

Ya I know the craze of Arun govil and yes your right beech me jo aye vo sab gone case they mere liye 🤣🤣 kabhi feeling hi nahi ayi Shri Ram jaise un logon ko dekhkar

Originally posted by: Niharika_17

Adbhut ramayan was itself imagination of Valmiki as he potrays ma Sita in supreme role there but I never like adbhut reason because it has so weird stories regarding ma Sita birth she is originated from the blood of rishis whom ravan killed first he took that pot in Lanka but then on mandodri insistance left it on lands of Mithila from so the mithila became barren then birth of ma Sita happened . So weird it is like I just love vr but other versions can also be read as they are written in bhakti bhav but jo maza vr padne me hai vo kise or me nahi

100 baat ki ek baat bata di niharika ne🫂❣️...

Saare versions ache hai par VR jaisa connect muje bhi kisi version mein feel nahi hua....VR is best to understand storyline and psychology of all characters in detail if we want to understand subtext of ramayan deeply....

Originally posted by: RamAayenge

100 baat ki ek baat bata di niharika ne🫂❣️...

Saare versions ache hai par VR jaisa connect muje bhi kisi version mein feel nahi hua....VR is best to understand storyline and psychology of all characters in detail if we want to understand subtext of ramayan deeply....

Le tum logone padhi hai books. Maine nahi padhi

Isliye yeh distortion ya namoone characters meri samaj mein aate hi nahi

Dekha Jaye toh itna complex nahi hai

But makers khichdi bana ke complex kar dete hai simple story ko

Originally posted by: Niharika_17

Ya authenticity wise rs ramayan and ndtv ramayan are good but ya rs ramayan is according to rcm mainly and in ndtv they followed incidents of vr too

But I can't connect with rs ramayan Arun govil looks too old for me as Shri Ram maybe generation thing so now sujay is imprinted in my heart as Shri Ram but if I liked someone before sujay as Shri Ram so he is gurmeet Chaudhry

RS ramayan has good amount of VR too....

Entire Yuddhkand,,,,was greatly influenced & taken frm VR only in RS ramayan,,,and even for that matter,,, Ayodhya kaand and Aranya kand too was having VR ke jyada parts plus whole coverage of Manas too...

Matlab VR Manas and kuch dusre versions ka accha mix hai RS Ramayan...

Ndtv as far as I know,,same to same RS Ramayan plus they added more backstories and more incidents frm other versions too like kritibaas ramayan etc...

Here also till now SR mein bhi Manas VR dono ka influence hai....Tv par series banate hue kabhi bhi full VR follow nahi karte makers,,,,,( I wish aisa ek din aaye jab full VR based Ramayan dekhne mile)....bcz kam logo ko pata hai VR as compared to Manas,,they always mix and match different versions.... But maintaining proper balance is the key here,,in character arc, in subtext,,,....jo even SR wale VR ke acc exactly nahi kar paaye hai( Celina has once given good detailed review over that,,,Ananya Di,disha di and maine bhi kai events pe same baat discuss ki thi)... Yuddhkand mein to major mess up hai,,, events sare le liye hai VR se....par placement of events,,,subtext,,, character arc of almost all characters,,,sab kuch apne hisaab se kar diya hai....yaha main prblm jo muje lagi as I hv mentioned it much back too,,manas ke acc character arc diya hai and events VR ke follow Kiya hai bahut jagah....VR ke hisaab se character arc of even Shri Ram is maintained Only till aranya kand,,,,then onwards Shri Ram ka character arc bhi Manas acc hi hai,,,, minimum human side of Ram,but mostly god side of Ram,,,yaha UK mein again Human side of Ram dikhaya Jayda inhone....subtext acha nikala hai inhone that's good.

But overall series is going good in many parts....and mess up in certain parts.... actors r gold here,,,, especially Sujay as Ram is imprinted in my mind....

Originally posted by: RamAayenge

RS ramayan has good amount of VR too....

Entire Yuddhkand,,,,was greatly influenced & taken frm VR only in RS ramayan,,,and even for that matter,,, Ayodhya kaand and Aranya kand too was having VR ke jyada parts plus whole coverage of Manas too...

Matlab VR Manas and kuch dusre versions ka accha mix hai RS Ramayan...

Ndtv as far as I know,,same to same RS Ramayan plus they added more backstories and more incidents frm other versions too like kritibaas ramayan etc...

Here also till now SR mein bhi Manas VR dono ka influence hai....Tv par series banate hue kabhi bhi full VR follow nahi karte makers,,,,,( I wish aisa ek din aaye jab full VR based Ramayan dekhne mile)....bcz kam logo ko pata hai VR as compared to Manas,,they always mix and match different versions.... But maintaining proper balance is the key here,,in character arc, in subtext,,,....jo even SR wale VR ke acc exactly nahi kar paaye hai... Yuddhkand mein to major mess up hai,,, events sare le liye hai VR se....par placement of events,,,subtext,,, character arc of almost all characters,,,sab kuch apne hisaab se kar diya hai....yaha main prblm jo muje lagi as I hv mentioned it much back too,,manas ke acc character arc diya hai and events VR ke follow Kiya hai bahut jagah....VR ke hisaab se character arc of even Shri Ram is maintained Only till aranya kand,,,,then onwards Shri Ram ka character arc bhi Manas acc hi hai,,,, minimum human side of Ram,but mostly god side of Ram,,,yaha UK mein again Human side of Ram dikhaya Jayda inhone....subtext acha nikala hai inhone that's good.

But overall series is going good in many parts....and mess up in certain parts.... actors r gold here,,,, especially Sujay as Ram is imprinted in my mind....

Correct mix and match Karo toh sahi Karo

Ek cheez vr se liya uska execution Manas se

Time line event mein bhi gadbad hai

Balance nahi isliye confusion jyada hai

Jo new generation hai jinhe kuch pata nahi woh yehi sahi samjengena

Ab yaha UK kaand mein to manas ka hai nahi bahut to mast chance tha VR follow karne ka...and we felt also na ki barring sasta ravan ,bhaaskarn wala,,and few other mishaps ( abhi jo laxman wala hua tha)....usse chodekar mostly story VR ke acc jaa rahi hai....mutual decision of Siya Ram for parityag we felt ki as per all ramayan tv series,,,aise hi dikahte hai,,,,as If waha pura VR follow karte to inconsistent lagta ShriRam ka part hi....soo accha kiya jo iss tarah se diya ki Sita ke saath saath Shri Ram ki plight dilemma handling and questions on this incident acche se clear hue ....

But I came to know ki yaha jitna ab tak dikhaya hai...jo acha sahi laga woh part bhi and jaha major gadbag laga(jo I mentioned above)....woh sab kuch exactly Anand ramayan se liya gaya hai....(source is YT mein likha tha kuch logo ne),,matlab mostly uk they r following Anand Ramayan only...

Matlab ab aisa hai bhi to Ansh ramayan ke mein batana chahiye na....to jaha mishap laga waha clarity hoti ....and yaha major VR and added mein other versions rakhe to jyada acha hoga....bcz anand Ramayan mein to last mein bilkul Alag hai Sita bhumi pravesh ke baad sabke kshama maangne par Mata laut aati hai and then happy ending etc ..... though its happy thought but fir aise to Sita bhumi pravesh ka main msg chala jaayega na....and further events till Shri Ram Mahaprasthan too shd not be cut....matlab kahi to VR ko main rakhe🤦...

Abhi jo Kush bada hai and Luv Chhota hai as per VR also and as all knows this fact well,,,SR wale says Luv bada kush Chhota,again YT wale says frm Anand ramayan,,,batao🤦)

Tho I feel jo karenge,,end of day thik subtext hi nikaalenge...

Originally posted by: chatterbox

Le tum logone padhi hai books. Maine nahi padhi

Isliye yeh distortion ya namoone characters meri samaj mein aate hi nahi

Dekha Jaye toh itna complex nahi hai

But makers khichdi bana ke complex kar dete hai simple story ko

Absolutely true words didi❣️🙌...

Originally posted by: RamAayenge

Ab yaha UK kaand mein to manas ka hai nahi bahut to mast chance tha VR follow karne ka...and we felt also na ki barring sasta ravan ,bhaaskarn wala,,and few other mishaps ( abhi jo laxman wala hua tha)....usse chodekar mostly story VR ke acc jaa rahi hai....mutual decision of Siya Ram for parityag we felt ki as per all ramayan tv series,,,aise hi dikahte hai,,,,as If waha pura VR follow karte to inconsistent lagta ShriRam ka part hi....soo accha kiya jo iss tarah se diya ki Sita ke saath saath Shri Ram ki plight dilemma handling and questions on this incident acche se clear hue ....

But I came to know ki yaha jitna ab tak dikhaya hai...jo acha sahi laga woh part bhi and jaha major gadbag laga(jo I mentioned above)....woh sab kuch exactly Anand ramayan se liya gaya hai....matlab mostly uk they r following Anand Ramayan only...

Matlab ab aisa hai bhi to Ansh ramayan ke mein batana chahiye na....to jaha mishap laga waha clarity hoti ....and yaha major VR and added mein other versions rakhe to jyada acha hoga....bcz anand Ramayan mein to last mein bilkul Alag hai Sita bhumi pravesh ke baad sabke kshama maangne par Mata laut aati hai and then happy ending etc ..... though its happy thought but fir aise to Sita bhumi pravesh ka main msg chala jaayega na....and further events till Shri Ram Mahaprasthan too shd not be cut....matlab kahi to VR ko main rakhe🤦.

Ohho Last para

Yeh toh poora weird hai

Dharti mein jaake fir lauti

This looks fiction to me

Ram avtaar ka end bhi toh hai na

Sita jayegi nahi toh ram avtaar kaise end hoga

Mahaprasthan sahi dikha de bas

Baaki i will accept as fiction only

Originally posted by: RamAayenge

RS ramayan has good amount of VR too....

Entire Yuddhkand,,,,was greatly influenced & taken frm VR only in RS ramayan,,,and even for that matter,,, Ayodhya kaand and Aranya kand too was having VR ke jyada parts plus whole coverage of Manas too...

Matlab VR Manas and kuch dusre versions ka accha mix hai RS Ramayan...

Ndtv as far as I know,,same to same RS Ramayan plus they added more backstories and more incidents frm other versions too like kritibaas ramayan etc...

Here also till now SR mein bhi Manas VR dono ka influence hai....Tv par series banate hue kabhi bhi full VR follow nahi karte makers,,,,,( I wish aisa ek din aaye jab full VR based Ramayan dekhne mile)....bcz kam logo ko pata hai VR as compared to Manas,,they always mix and match different versions.... But maintaining proper balance is the key here,,in character arc, in subtext,,,....jo even SR wale VR ke acc exactly nahi kar paaye hai( Celina has once given good detailed review over that,,,Ananya Di,disha di and maine bhi kai events pe same baat discuss ki thi)... Yuddhkand mein to major mess up hai,,, events sare le liye hai VR se....par placement of events,,,subtext,,, character arc of almost all characters,,,sab kuch apne hisaab se kar diya hai....yaha main prblm jo muje lagi as I hv mentioned it much back too,,manas ke acc character arc diya hai and events VR ke follow Kiya hai bahut jagah....VR ke hisaab se character arc of even Shri Ram is maintained Only till aranya kand,,,,then onwards Shri Ram ka character arc bhi Manas acc hi hai,,,, minimum human side of Ram,but mostly god side of Ram,,,yaha UK mein again Human side of Ram dikhaya Jayda inhone....subtext acha nikala hai inhone that's good.

But overall series is going good in many parts....and mess up in certain parts.... actors r gold here,,,, especially Sujay as Ram is imprinted in my mind....

Exactly facts were according to vr but they messed up in presentation and mostly it was with lakshman ji war scenes baki tab bhi theek they . Every show presents yudh kand mainly according to vr because in rcm it's different there in first day itself lakshman ji get injured from meghnad brahma shakti but in rs ramayan and ndtv one also parastha is shown as ravan son according to rcm but in sr it was correct he was ravan maternal uncle and his vadh was also shown by nel .