Originally posted by: Skepblun
Ra One is not experimental. Superhero or sci-fi films are not new to India.
The rest of what you wrote is just same stuff which fans say in defense.
He did stick to romance - chose KHNH over Munnabhai MBBS, KANK over RDB. He may have done a Swades, Don series, CDI but time to time has continued to belt out romantic films too.
Yes Sanjay Dutt and Aamir Khan fit those films perfectly. It's hard to imagine anyone else in those films, still his choices have reflected on his career in India.
We're just going in circles here!
I mean for HIM, and even movie too to an extent because there was a hell lot of new technology involved in that.
Yeah, of course it would be. Would you really expect us to keep changing perspectives because someone else thinks otherwise? And well if you say its defense, so be it assuming you attacked.
EXACTLY my point. He wants to do that. So? He chose them over non-romantic movies but he did do CDI ans Swades too. Where is his fault in this? That he chucked RDB and Munnabhai without feigning they would be massive hits which could turn him around?
His choices has done nothing to his image apart from the part that now people want to prey on actors labelling them as a lil below standard if they don't give 100 crore plus. Let's not pretend that it doesn't happen. He still will be the unbeatable international superstar and even with all this, he will be remembered most for his romantic roles.
Like I said, of course we are. You posed a question and I had and continue to have only one answer. So yeah circles is pretty much where we are and will go unless you want to bring in an entire new aspect to picture so we can discuss. But at this point, I stay true to what I said in all my replies to this post.
Anupamaa
2