Posted:
Agree with you Kaku. PKYEK showed us the soulmate concept so much better than this.
Naveen
So according to Gul herself the marriage is invalid? Well it may be so. As it is Ansh did not know what he was doing. I am getting hope from you as to why he is supporting Ruby against even Ved. He is actually trying to uphold Ved choice for him.
Naveen, I know you follow/ or used to follow (whichever is correct) IB, but never knew you followed DBO...i hv read a couple of ff/os by you in IB forum and I must say you're one terrific writer...it would be great if you can write something on PiAnsh, time permitting...
I'll not discuss about the legal aspects regarding marriage as I feel it won't be valid in the reel world. . Yes when Rikara got married they were in their senses, but the intent to marry was not their on Om's part..for him it was just a way to save Gauri from the mob and he himself didn't know that it would be construed as marriage and he made himself clear in the next shot (though I hated the way he just pushed Gauri). ..And as far as Rudy and Soumya marriage is concerned, you and I we both know the reason why it was scrapped... So am not getting in to details... So mostly I will agree with what Indu said that it depends on the creatives...it depends on their whims and they can swing it either ways...Regarding Ansh stopping Ved from forcibly trying to get Ruby to arti, you gave an alternate view which I think maybe right.. I never thought from that angle...silly me... I'm so frustrated with whatever is happening that of late I'm having a tunnel vision...this is the beauty of discussion...a constructive discussion always helps... And moreover I never wanted to impose my views... Apologies if you felt it that way..Off topic, have you watched "pyaar ki ye Ek kahani"...it used to air on star one and had Vivian Dsena and Sukirti Khandpal as lead.. It was also supernatural genre, with soul mate trope.. .There ml erases fl's memories of him, or we can say that he manipulated with her memory . And despite loosing her memories fl involuntarily used to come to the spot where the ml was buried... And after that when he comes out from his ice tomb, she's drawn to him despite him being rude and obnoxious. ...for me that's what being soul mate is all about at least in the supernatural genre, as in reality I don't believe in these stuff..."Abhay Raichand" is epic and I see many Abhiya fans here..@Tia... No I haven't watched the series which you mentioned...made a note of it and will try to catch up once I have time...Yes I agree with you that there's nothing more horrendous than mental possession... Mental/emotional trauma surpasses the physical injury /wounds/trauma. And Ansh jumping from the terrace was horrible...in fact my heart goes out to him for the fact that whatever he did he wasn't aware of it, but despite not being at fault he'll have to bear the consequences..
Originally posted by: slippery_chilka
Call me Tia. ðOk, question. Were any of them under mind control when these marriages happened in DBO? No, right? That's your answer. Mind control makes this "marriage" null and void.Have you seen Marvel's Jessica Jones? If you haven't, you should. t's an amazing show. Jessica has super powers and the villain Kilgrave fell for her and his power was mind control. He made her kill, he raped her and he made her believe she loved him. The whole of season one was she trying to run from him, dealing with her PTSD and blaming herself but you know what the lesson was of that season? The culprit was Kilgrave, not her. She was totally innocent. By making her kill, the blood was on Kilgraves hands and not hers. Luke Cage, the hero, her future husband's wife was killed by Jessica on Kilgrave's orders. Luke himself was mind controlled in the finale to kill Jessica. And both of them recognised that Kilgrave was the culprit not each other. As soon as she made peace with that, she stopped hating herself.The worst part was watching Kilgrave mindcontrol people. Someone looked at him funny = gouge your eyes out. Someone touched him without permission = burn your own hand or cut it off with that dull butter knife. Someone shouted at him = Go bash your head on that wall till you die. Someone annoyed him = You will shoot your whole family ruthlessly.Are you all aware that mind control is a mental rape? It's gives the victims PTSD which Jessica has. Because you loose one of the most precious thing. Free Will. If you watch the show you will realise how terrible it is to not have freewill. You cannot say no to the simplest thing. No, I don't want to eat dal. No, I don't want to jump. No, I don't want to cook and then there's this, an assault of the worst kind: No, I don't want to have sex with you.We have already seen Ansh having no free will. He jumped off his building because Ruby instructed him to. Would you call this a marriage?
Naveen if you get time please write a feel good happy romantic FF on PiAn with the supernatural element
@akruti: When the show started they knew the story and was following it because it was suppose to be a finite series, but then the show got good TRP's and the show got extension, now the writers seems to be confused about how and where to take the story, that's why there seems to be so many loopholes and the story at most times feels all over the place. I am still hoping that this or next week we should get a better story and well balanced episodes.
comment:
p_commentcount