Originally posted by: shibz
gals derz a mis-understanding...if u read again all posts from the beginin clearly..perhaps u wil understand wat we mean...the topic starter opened d topic coz she found dose scenes similar..she isn't aware dat such scenes r common in such love stories...same goes2 Zaneb(KMH_Arjuhi). So dats wat sum of us xplained initially dat d scenes do remind of KMH but dey r common scenes.. later i specially went off d topic..gave hype 2 Prasha instead of Geet n Anjali n Me got busy wit dat..if u see our discussions..it was light hearted..we made the best use of it 2 create humor around..laughin n havin fun in our own world deviating from the topic.. one gal said dat the boss associate thing started wit KTH n not KMH...i agree wit her coz i hav seen KTH as well but for me KMH was different enuf 2 b my sole favorite..i din argue wit her wit the differences b/w KTH n KMH.. Den came Nimra...U gave ur opinion..fine i like it..but coz u dun find it similar doesnt mean others shud'nt find it.. now m gettin really angry..Zabardasti o wat??? den came kavya..she gave her opinion in a very nice way too..she dint say anythin ill bout Geet!! ...m sorry Nimra but u misunderstood her..n gav her a reply like she attacked u personally wer as she had jus given her view.. this topic got serious from den.. until den der was peaceful discussions goin on here..now hu knew Geet fans visit dis forum?😕 u said comparing the 2 shows wud b childish! xactly..y did u take a child's topic or view so seriously..i mean the topic starter is kritika...she is a child n same goes2 zaneb..if she said the makers of Geet r copy caters n dat forced u 2 comment here den again she is also a child..she hasnt watched many serials n dat 2 Indian i think jus KMH..not sure though..
i dun believ it..everyday i post sumthin here jus2 make u understand wat we feel n mean but u simply dun wan2 understand coz u think we r offensive 2 Geet...after reading your last post yesterday..i was feelin guilty n sad...but not anymore coz your madly in love wit Geet or rather obsessed..M xtremely sorry but i m cryin here jus2 make u understand wat we think..
..if u see properly...it was u hu started 2 compare KMH wit Geet..started 2 talk high bout it..dats not fair..nw dat u say y dis topic Geet in KMH forum..!! This topic here is not offensive..Yes comparison topics r not allowed but in polls...also it wud b offensive if Maaneet n Arjuhi wer a part of the same sho KMH. but dis is a totally diff forum..Geet reminds us of KMH coz we miss KMH terribly..dat does not mean we r comparin the 2 shows.. yes it wud b wrong if sumbody opened this topic in Geet forum..den the topic wud get xtremely hot witin no tym.. but if KMHians r havin healthy discussions here y shud it bother u soo much!! i m aware of ppl comparin Arjuhi 2 Maaneet outside dis forum n perhaps outside dis site n sayin dat Maaneet r better dan Arjuhi n dat thei chemistry is better dan Arjuhi..now dat hurts specially wen it cums from sumbody hu used2 b a die-hard fan of Arjuhi. M sure u r aware of dat too..so wats yo contribution der? did u defend Arjuhi? Probably dat is wat Tanu was hurt for..Besides its not a handful of KMH fans hu think its similar 2 KMH..but so many ppl think so..can u go around convincin everyone..no its different..
wen KMH came on air...everyone compared it 2 veer zaara includin me..but the comparison was limited 2 the jail-lawyer scenes n flasbac only..KMH went on 2 make its own identity ( dat 2day ppl say dat Tere Liye is inspired by KMH..no not KMH fans but others say dat..i hav seen..)..many ppl den started 2 believ dat KMH was better dan VZ..but i dun think so..bein a fan of VZ as well...both r beautiful love stories...both touched my heart..made me cry...but media even 2day says dat KMH was inspired by a blockbuster movie veer zaara..so shud i write 2 d media...no your wrong...KMH was different..?
dats the way it goes...its a chain...so if sum ppl find it similar...wats wrong? wats der 2 feel so insecure bout it?...u watch it in a different perspectiv..
If Maaneet shudnt b compared wit Arjuhi den Geet needs 2 make its own identity...like how the show started off wit a new concept..the current plot is bein over-hyped..n KMH inspite of the similarities initially, den surpassed all of dem wit a very different n the best story line along wit the passion n intense dat we love KMH n not watched o loved any drama after dat..😊
For KMHians...its hard 2 convince dem 2 love any other sho..for KMH was soo gud...2 b very honest i dun believ KMH2 can b as beautiful as KMH.. so the creatives of KMH2 wil hav a hard tym pleasin Me n i believ many like me..😛
all dis while i tried my best 2 b indifferent from yo serious posts coz i din wan2 hurt a sweet friend like u...but this post is surely goin2 bother u..
@kash: long tym haan..wat u busy wit? wat happened2 yo siggie btw..😉he he.. n Yes! i kno its difficult 2 understand our perspectiv but we r not comparin KMH 2 Geet..we kno the story lines r poles apart...its jus the scenes dat remind of KMH for us..😳n dat was the discussion initially n hope it ends wit the same..😛 Also..i agree der wer scenes in KMH copied from shows befor KMH coz i hav not missed any of dose shows but wateva was copied was very very few..actually jus 2 o 3 n was given a totally different touch..moreova dey wer taken frm the earlier Balaji shows itself n Balaji's creatives r well known for re-usin plots...howeva the ratio of reuse in KMH was less..d whole team did thei best in makin it one hell of a rockin show😛dat the shows dat came after KMH started 2 copy scenes n plots frm KMH...dun wan2 start dem again...the list goes long🥱
sorry Shibz, i missed your long post. Just saw it now.....and read all. 😊
like i said earlier, I didn't mean to hurt anyone. I didn't answer as if i was attacked personally to anyone.....if something made all of you mad then i can be mad equally right. 😊 i don't mind you can say anything to the show - Geet but all i said was....if i hear anything negative about the characters, i would be offended just like for KMH. So i think you did say something negative about Maan in the earlier posts and that stirred some anger in me.....yet i didn't say anything 😊 Talking about the show is another thing....talking about the characters of the show is something else...and that could become personal sometimes....😊
I don't remember who mentioned that why are there Geet fans here. Well, to answer that....i am a big KMH fan which alot of people are failing to believe.....which is just too funny and sad at the same time........because i know what i've been doing for KMH with all th girls and then i get this kind of reaction back....
anyways...i was saying that i am a big and loyal fan of KMH...i visited this forum and happened to see this thread. (now don't say KMH fans can't watch or love any other shows) so i'm also one of the fans who happened to watch this other show and loved. I think i'm clear with this now.
Back to Shibz😊..... @Red, i don't know many people here....just a few from fb...i have no idea about the starter of the topic whether she's a child or not.....so it's my fault that i took her views seriously..........😊
@Green, Like i said...i'm not here to convince anyone that Geet is the best show....i was just sharing my views.....so i believe you are not convincing me either that Geet is similar to KMH or not an interesting show right? so we're all good.....😊 My obsession did not end at KMH....time changes....people change....and we move on too....that goes for everyone here whether you believe or not...though i will always keep KMH close to my heart....😊
@Orange, and i'm also doing the same since last week 😊.....and this is not limited to I-F....people are even talking about it on fb asking me why am i into this new show...and why going to their wall.......you can imagine how mad i could get...😊 but still keeping calm......and then people say it's really your personal choice whether you want to watch or not....so where's my personal choice and space??😊 (shibz, this is not for you...just a random comment)
@Blue, i'm sorry but i don't know Kavya either.......and i don't know where i replied her rudely or misunderstood her......please let me know😊
@Black, this is my first post. take a look.....😊
Hi Girls, Just came by this post! 😊
I agree with most of you. Infact, i started watching Geet about 3 weeks ago only because someone on Adda had mentioned that it has a glimpse of KMH so i was too eager to see it. Good thing it started only about 3 months ago....i didn't have to watch toooo many episodes and neither i planned to. But once i started watching, it became an addiction! 😊 Now let me be honest here, KMH was the very first indian serial that i watched and loved to the core!......and the second would be GEET! 😉 I definately saw glimpses of Arjun in Maan...but after a few more episodes, it all started to fade away. Geet has a totally different storyline. The only smililarity is Secretary-Boss relation. Those love scenes are a must when it comes to such love stories.😊
Yes, nothing ever be like KMH...and its BG music! I simply stopped comparing becuase honestly, the story of Geet took a different turn after sometime. 😊
YES! the dress Arohi wore was worn by another girl..even i noticed it! hehe! 😆
Even i could never think of any other show except KMH but Geet has become my new addiction! There's nothing to compare the two because it can't be compared!😊
KMH is still very dear and near to my heart.......and i'm so excited for the new season!😉
so i was clearly not the one who starting comparing Geet with KMH. Infact, before i came in...there were 3 pages of posts talking about Geet being similar to KMH😊
Perhaps this is the post you're talking about where i misunderstood Kavya.
Originally posted by kavyasam I too saw few episode, first didnt like it the fact that two brothers for a same girl. after few epis it is looking okay, can discuss abt it there. some interesting topics going on in that forum. but Arjuhi is Arjuhi na, nothing can surpass them for me, their acting is natural .
My Reply:
Two brothers are not for the same girl. It's just Maan....😊 His younger brother married her for some reason....but he is not after her. Shuru se dekho toa theek se samajh aati hai story ki...😊
I love Geet's acting...i think she's very natural...whereas Maan needs some improvements....just like Karan needed some polishing....but eventually he touched perfection.😊
Now i can't see anything that could be rude or misunderstanding......@blue, if this is what you're talking about....then it was a simple sentence....many people are not following GEET regularly yet making comments as if they've watched the entire soap till now.....so thats why i suggested to her that if she has not watched then do that because if she did......she would have known that two brothers are not after the same girl😊
P.S: please let her know that i mentioned her name a few times in case she doesn't read this. I don't want to talk about anyone without their presence....espacially when i don't know them😊
@Yellow, nothing is bothering me......infact i tried to stop the topic before it got worst because i didn't want to argue or fight with anyone..but looks like the topic continued😊
@Brown, not a single time, i said that Geet has better chemistry than KMH or Arjuhi is better than Maaneet. And i cleared to Tanu why i said which hurt her. I hope she read it😊
Plus, there is nothing that came out of my mouth that indicates that I was a die-hard fan of KMH and now not defending it. I defend KMH where it needs to be defended and i've done that million times before😊 Now the case is with a show that is also my favorite....yet i never said that it could ever be better than KMH. My point for writing here is not trying to defend Geet but rather trying to point out the fact that it is not similar to KMH....and Geet producers are not "copycaters" as someone has mentioned earlier in this thread.😊 My only point is....(generally speaking) if you don't like Geet or not interested to watch it then don't....i'm not going to convince anyone....but that doesn't mean anyone can start saying anything to Geet.😊 That would also be offensive to Geet's fans as KMH fans are hurt from my posts eventhough i never meant to hurt anyone. Now i feel like i'm the most misunderstood person here at this time......because all my posts have been taken wrongly...😊 I am just so tired of seeing posts here and on fb where literally ALL KMH fans are saying that Geet is rubbish because it is either similar to KMH or the chemistry of Maaneet is not like Arjuhi......which is so so odd to me hearing this from KMH die hard fans because they are the ones trying to look at Geet through KMH eye....
I admit that it reminds alot of people of KMH....it happened to me too...at first few epis....then i started thinking....nothng can be compared to KMH in this show...this is different.....so thats wat i felt and did....perhaps people are still misunderstanding me😊
@ Last Black, Geet's main concept is the social issue......KMH very different.😊
Plus, if there are no critics....or there are no downfalls, the show will never be successful.😊 If Geet is being over-hyped then it has better chances of being successful since so many fans will be there to critic it and make things better.
Plus, (i won't mention anything in KMH) the biggest downfall was the abrupt closing of KMH. The way fans were treated falsely......inspite of so many loyal fans, the TRP's dropped ending the show when we didn't want it to end. From there, the fans gathered together....make numerous petitions....started campaigns...spammed sbs and other walls...flooded media's mailboxes....requested interviews............and what did we get at the end.....a sequence of KMH...😊 so you see how fans can change the situation.........and how even opposing comments/critcs can make something better.😊 If Geet needs an identity then it also needs time and lovely fans to support it.😊
I'm equally a participant in getting back KMH like everyone here....and it hurts to see such reactions from fellow fans........though i'm not active on I-F that much....i'm a regular user of fb....and have spent my entire nights running the campaigns there....
P.S: I was not on FB neither I-F......at the time of KMH. The secret is....i watched the first episode of KMH exactly one week after it went off-air.....and watched the entire show in 2 weeks. Then i joined FB.....searched for Karan Kritika like mad.....and started to make wonderful new friends.😊
So you can imagine how i managed to take 9 months of beautiful world into 2 weeks. I can proudly say that i am a KMH/Arjuhi fan and will always be 😊 and honestly, i am even more eager for it to start again because i missed all the fun and madness before....but now i want to experience it.😊
take care all.....and no offense to anyone here....hope i cleared myself😊
Edited by Nimz-KMH - 14 years ago
comment:
p_commentcount