Originally posted by: kiran_rd
I 100% agree with Viashali...I started watching the show becoz of Irfan & than started liking nihira Rehman sanchita viashali seeram, Anweesha is an overdose for seeing so much in reality shows whereas sharib & aneek are drama piece only for trp nothing special. So indeed judges are biased + I m highly disappointed by Shan attitude towards viashali..a contestant of her callibre do deserve respect & the way he behaved simply unacceptable. this show need only drama pieces to have trp. I feel so bad that the way sreeram is used or protrayed in the show otherwise in inndian idol he was really humble gentleman & won on merit by giving good performances I wonder what has happened here. Instead of Akshana, aneek & sharib either nihira viashali aur sanchita desrved to be in top 6 becoz of their singing & there eviction shows judges biased attitude that is being rightly pointed by viashali ..shan may be a good singer but he proved to be a pathetic judge...now my only hope is Irfan if he doesn't make to top than its final bye wesay bhee Indian idol has started & its way way better than this crap
Vaishali needs to grow up. She could have raised this point at the occurance of the "incident". Maybe, just maybe if she watched what she said she could have been competing for th champion spot. Well she burnt herself. As for the arrogance that the she left the stage with was utterly disgusting. She should not take part in such competetions if she cant handle the heat. Sharib is good at what he does, too bad jealousy got the better of Vaishali. I am glad she was elimanated.👏 The show doesnt need negative people like her. Good riddens to Vaishali.
I was saying that Sharib is such a slimy and annoying character that the judges would really not favour him.As you rightly pointed out, he is arrogant and loudmouthed. But these judges are very tolerant. They tolerate so much attitude from all these nobodies like Shivam, Vaishali, Sanchita, Soniya and Sharib.I don't think the judges have given Sharib special treatment. Yes, you may feel that they gave him more marks than he deserved and they gave Nihira less marks than she deserved. But I do not think that is because they are in awe of Sharib and not of Nihira. Instead, they probably thought Sharib and Nihira actually deserved those marks.Music is very subjective. You can say that in your opinion Nihira was underscored and Sharib was overscored. You can say that the judges' scores were wrong. But I think it is very unfair to question their integrity and say that the judges are biased.We have seen in this show that based on the judges' marks that Nihira has gained the top two position more than once.
I thoroughly agree with the bolded point. Everyone here is fighting over who is the best. Each person's respective favorite is the best according to that person. But there is mostly a consensus over the fact that the judges are biased towards some other contestant who is not that person's favorite and biased against that person's favorite. Honestly, are any of us qualified to pass judgement over the esteemed judges' judgement? Yes, if someone like Rahat Fateh Ali, Shankar Mahadevan or someone else of their stature would comment here saying that these judges are biased it would make sense. But common people like us have no right to judge them. And after seeing so many of these reality shows, don't we realize that all this drama is created by the channel just for trp? It seems strange to me that people still get affected by all this.
comment:
p_commentcount