Bad judging by Anu and salim - Page 2

Originally posted by: sushrutapandey

Frankly after watching a few episodes, I feel Salim is the worst judge. His comments are never intelligent and merely superficial. Anu Malik never usually disses a person who has sung well though he gets carried away sometimes. Sunidhi is definitely the best judge out there.

I also felt that Anu was a bit harsh against Swaroop 🤔

Arpita was screaching while singing bindiya chamkegi. Poor Lata Mangeshkar must be horrified. Arpita's voice suits Asha Bhosle or Kavita Krishnamurti numbers.

Same with Manisha. She was bad with Yeh galiyan.

Swaroop too killed Chithi aayegi

but yash was good this time,probably his best performance on idol😆..Anu ji always says senseless things,ignoree..!!

Originally posted by: mintyblue

It seems judges Anu and Salim are too partial to the boys. Sunidhi always gives rational and balanced judgement. Salim I am sorry to say has gone Anu Malik's way and his comments can easily be passed over. He was much better in the beginning, but now seems to bask in his smile and forget to point out the nuances. Sunidhi has proved her credentials as a judge- she rocks👏👏👏

Why on earth did Yashraj get such good comments from Anu and salim? This was the point when he needed to go, instead Swaroop who did a much better job was hauled up.😡 Just because Swaroop is form a rural area Anu has no right to insult him ,and be patronising to him. I HATED his attitude towards swaroop🤢 swaroop deserves to mobve ahead.

As for the girls, Salim said to Arpita she could have done better. Arpita was easily the best among girls today. yet she got lukewarm comments from Salim. Anu was still OK, Arpita's song was really tough and she did a great job, never slipping into falsetto. yet salim could not give constructive criticism to Bhoomi, who sliipped in sur more than once.

Overall Sunidhi is the only judge worth listening to today⭐️ of course, Pyarelaal jee was awesome as well, giving apt comments in a short and sweet manner😊

I used to think judges were biased towards Swaroop until yesterday's episode. Swaroop did not sing well and the judges told him that. But yes, anu was too harsha and i did not like the way he dissed him off. It was very insulting for Sawroop and felt very bad for him.

Seriously, Exactally My point of view. Sawroop was so much better then Yashraj and his comments were so rude.

Originally posted by: b.sandhu

can u please tell me what he said to swaroop the written update hasn't been done and I can't watch the epi until another couple of hours.
thank you
cheers:)

he said tum gaon se aaye ho, samajhte ho ki tum raja ho, bhool jao is ko, un do(two) judges ne to kuchh nahin kaha, lekin mein kahoonga, ki, it is bad singing.

mean If you came from village, you think that you are king, but forget it, those two judges did not say anything, i would say , it is bad singing.

Anu's face was sad on 31st may too when swaroop sang , sohni de nakhre sohne lagde
anu did not appreciate this song too at all

It does not matter, swaroop is folk singer, he can sing those folk and sufi songs which are already available in hindi films, in that way, he would be number one.

Also every style of composer has made such songs which are similar to folk and sufi songs. Swaroop could not select song suitable for his voice.

It is not all the time, next time, he would sing definitely marvelous because he has no problem in singing but his voice does not suit slow songs. Therefor he should select high range songs.
Moreover, in all the singing competition, many singers has sung sufi filmi songs as well as folk songs. Many rock songs are similar to folk. for example: chalat musafir moh liya re is folk song but it is film song. Either swaroop have no idiea about selection of song or judges are always selecting song for these singer, I am confused that how did he choose : chitthi aayi re

I am agree with your comments, minty blue comments and many other.

I too felt really bad for Swaroop...even manisha has done some really bad singing but Anu never said she sang badly... even tia...

Anu Malik has no right to do that... maybe he could have spoken to Swaroop after the show or something...not in front of everyone like that...Swaroop was almost crying...he looked really hurt...I hope inshallah he sings really well next time and does not go out...seriously..just to show Anu Malik...